New York Fed survey shows consumers expect inflation to hit 3.9% in next year

Consumers expect inflation to run hotter over the next year than at any point since May 2023, a signal that complicates the Federal Reserve’s debate over how quickly to keep cutting interest rates. The New York Fed’s Survey of Consumer Expectations for September showed households bracing for both higher prices and heavier spending, even as the central bank’s preferred inflation gauge came in softer than forecast in August.

• One-year inflation expectations rose to 3.9%, up 0.3 percentage point from August and the highest near-term level since May 2023, when it was 4.1%.
• Expected household spending growth climbed to 5.5%, also up 0.3 percentage point and the highest since May 2023.
• Markets largely expect the Federal Open Market Committee to hold its benchmark rate steady at its meeting later this month.

• 3.9% one-year inflation outlook, up from August but below May 2023’s 4.1%
• 5.5% expected spending growth, up 0.3 point from August’s reading
• 2.35% five-year breakeven rate, its highest point so far this year
• 3.75%-4% current Fed funds target range ahead of October’s meeting

The report, first detailed by CNBC, lands at a delicate moment for policymakers. Inflation remains well above the Fed’s 2% target even as officials weigh further rate moves.

One-year inflation view jumps to 3.9%, matching pre-2023 highs

The median one-year inflation expectation of 3.9% marks the sharpest near-term reading since May 2023, when the figure stood at 4.1%, according to the New York Fed’s survey. That earlier period came during a stretch of aggressive rate hikes aimed at taming post-pandemic price pressures, making the latest jump notable as a reference point for how unanchored short-term expectations have become again.

Household spending expectations moved in tandem, rising to 5.5% from 5.2% in August. Both figures increased by the same 0.3 percentage point margin month over month, suggesting consumers are bracing simultaneously for pricier goods and their own heavier outlays rather than one driving the other independently.

The timing is notable because it contrasts with incoming hard data. Inflation in August came in lower than expected according to the Fed’s preferred gauge, even as consumer sentiment on future prices worsened.

Longer-run expectations stay anchored near 3%

Further out on the timeline, the survey found expectations holding closer to the Fed’s comfort zone. The three-year inflation expectation edged up just 0.1 percentage point to 3.3%, while the five-year view was unchanged at 3%, both far steadier than the one-year reading’s 0.3-point jump.

Bond markets are telling a similar story through a separate channel. The five-year breakeven rate, a measure derived from the gap between nominal and inflation-protected Treasury yields, sits near its highest level of the year at 2.35%. Treasury yields more broadly have been climbing in recent weeks to levels not seen since the early part of the century, a backdrop that tends to accompany firmer long-run inflation pricing even when survey data show it holding near target.

Williams signals patience as futures price a tougher Fed path

New York Fed President John Williams has joined other officials in recent days arguing that policymakers can afford to take their time evaluating where rates should ultimately settle. The current fed funds target range stands at 3.75% to 4%, and markets widely expect the FOMC to leave it unchanged when it meets later in October.

But futures markets are not pricing uniform ease ahead. Fed funds futures contracts imply a rate of 5.58% in five years, well above today’s 3.75%-4% range and a sign traders see a more aggressive central bank path over the medium term than the current policy stance suggests.

Fed officials have long treated expectations data as a leading indicator of actual inflation, since households and businesses that anticipate higher prices tend to adjust wages and pricing decisions accordingly. That feedback loop is part of why a jump in the one-year reading, even alongside softer realized inflation data, carries weight inside the FOMC’s deliberations.

The BlockWest read. The gap between a cooling August inflation print and a hotter one-year consumer outlook puts the Fed in a position where survey psychology, not hard data, may constrain how fast it cuts. For corporate treasurers and crypto-adjacent balance sheets holding Treasury-linked collateral, the 5.58% five-year futures implied rate matters more than this month’s hold decision, since it signals markets expect borrowing costs to stay elevated far longer than headline inflation data alone would justify.

The FOMC’s next policy decision comes later in October, with markets betting on a hold at the 3.75%-4% range even as five-year futures price a 5.58% rate down the line. Whether Williams and his colleagues can keep near-term inflation expectations from feeding into actual price and wage decisions will be the test watched most closely before the Fed’s next move.

BlockWest is a news publication. Nothing here is investment advice. Read our disclaimer and editorial policy.