Key takeaways
- Scroll is a zero-knowledge proof-based rollup scaling solution for Ethereum that makes transactions cheaper and faster for developers and users.
- US regulatory uncertainty from enforcement actions by the SEC and CFTC against platforms like Coinbase and Binance is impeding innovation and causing project teams to explore other jurisdictions.
- Enforcement decisions like the Ripple case create confusion because they distinguish between primary and secondary offerings in ways that don't align with traditional securities law principles.
- Crypto companies are increasingly relocating to Asia, particularly Hong Kong and Singapore, to escape US regulatory scrutiny despite the US leading in blockchain technology innovation.
- Legitimate crypto projects face similar regulatory pressure as fraudulent ones like FTX, making it difficult for good builders to operate confidently in the US market.
US enforcement and the chilling effect
Ashton Addison: What are the most important regulatory topics in the US right now?▶ 02:18
Patricia Ho: The US has led innovation in decentralized finance and blockchain technology. What has been less fortunate is the regulatory uncertainty of the past year and a half. We see it in high-profile news like the FTX trial and in numerous enforcement actions by the SEC and CFTC, against large platforms like Coinbase and Binance and against smaller projects. It impedes innovation. Many US-based teams I talk to are cautious about being high-profile, and they think about whether they need to block US users from their apps. They want to build, but what they build may not suit the US market, so they look to Europe and Asia. In the past three to six months I've seen a lot of teams exploring setting up in Hong Kong and Singapore. Some of these cases are easier to understand than others. In the Ripple case, the decision turned on whether something was offered to institutional investors on a primary basis or to retail investors on a secondary exchange. That isn't really logical, because the US Howey test for determining what is a security doesn't make that distinction between a primary offer and a secondary transaction. Even Coinbase, which has engaged with regulators for many years, isn't spared. The SEC has alleged that staking as a service is an offering of securities. I don't think we'll see much more clarity until after the election and until Congress can make clearer laws, which will take time.
Ashton: Biden has told Congress to crack down more, yet enforcement seems aimed at the wrong companies. Is that why new companies are looking at other markets?▶ 06:39
Patricia: Yes, I think that is unfortunately the consequence of a series of enforcement actions and decisions that are not very logical on a legal-principle basis. With bad players like FTX, there was clearly a fraudulent element to the operations. I agree with the prosecutors that when an operation is fraudulent, it doesn't matter whether you're in crypto or any other industry. We need to protect all investors against fraud. It is unfortunate that crypto and the good builders in it get a hard time just by association with being in the same industry. With the FTX trial now more settled, and sentencing due in March, the initial excitement and focus has gone down. I hope the industry can go back to building and stay tuned to the opportunities around the world.
I am very bullish on the Middle East.
Hong Kong rolls out the welcome mat
Ashton: Singapore and Hong Kong are attracting a lot of companies. Why are they going there, and is it the opposite of the US, with doors open and an invitation to come in?▶ 09:22
Patricia: It is a bit like that, no exaggeration intended. That's my observation, and it's shared by a lot of friends who have come here from Europe and the US in the past few months. Last October, Hong Kong came out with a government policy to support becoming the next global hub for virtual assets. It is a coordinated effort between policymakers, the government, regulators and the ecosystem, and they are encouraging web3 and virtual asset businesses to come and set up. It is actually very accessible to have meetings with regulators in Hong Kong. That includes the Securities and Futures Commission, the securities regulator, and the Hong Kong Monetary Authority, which is going to be the stablecoin regulator. There is a recognition that the industry is growing at a very innovative pace, so regulators want to understand DeFi, the need for liquidity, how it differs from traditional financial institutions, and where crypto and traditional finance can bridge gaps. The discussions I've taken part in with the HKMA on stablecoins have been very open and transparent. On the regulation side, a lot of work has already been done. Hong Kong enacted a virtual asset service provider regime in June this year. It allows crypto trading platforms to apply for a license to operate in the city, and it is open to retail investors. There are significant requirements around custody, segregation of client assets, and policies, procedures and risk management, all the things you would expect from a fully fledged regime. But at least there is a way, and it's very clear how you get there.
Stablecoins: who regulates, who leads
Ashton: What regulation applies to stablecoins and DeFi, and what is needed for those parts of the industry to grow?▶ 12:30
Patricia: Stablecoins are a really hot and important topic. I feel they will be the catalyst to bring on the next billion users, including all the traditional finance and fintech players. They are also critically important as a trading pair for crypto assets. Hong Kong, Singapore and the UK already have government policy supporting a stablecoin regime. Singapore announced a framework. Hong Kong is due to announce a consultation on a Hong Kong dollar stablecoin. At the end of October, the UK announced its plan for a UK stablecoin to be used as a means of retail payment. Regulators are starting with the simplest form: stablecoins referenced to a fiat currency and fully backed by reserve assets. To your point about maintaining stability, they are starting with the safest types, the ones where you can point to full backing reserves.
Ashton: Where is innovation being led in Europe, and how far along are they compared with the rest of the world?▶ 14:53
Patricia: London is becoming a hub for some crypto projects, and I think France is as well. France is part of the European Union, so it has its own comprehensive regime under MiCA, which has quite rigorous regulatory standards. Elsewhere in Europe, I do think the UK is going to be one of the innovative centers. It also benefits from being traditionally a major international financial center. For a stablecoin to be sustainable and used by many people, it comes down to liquidity. You need a very deep liquidity and trading market for the stablecoin to take off and be widely adopted.
Ashton: Do you think USDT and USDC will remain the main stablecoins for years to come, given the experiments with decentralized and differently backed alternatives?▶ 16:06
Patricia: They've taken very different paths. It is quite obvious that Circle is going down the license route. They engage with a number of regulators globally, including in Asia, and they want to serve traditional finance and work with institutions to increase adoption of USDC. Tether is actually the most used stablecoin from a crypto-native perspective. A lot of DeFi protocols and trading pairs use USDT. They are also becoming more visible, with a new CEO who was previously their CTO. Time will tell whether they go down a more regulated path or continue as they are, which is very impactful for the crypto-native ecosystem. As to whether those two will stay dominant, I don't know. But I think there is space for innovation beyond fiat-referenced stablecoins. We can see Maker's stablecoins and even Curve's, and there is a lot of innovation in the stabilization mechanism. Regulators are not ready to give recognition to algorithmic stablecoins just yet, partly because of the collapse of Luna last year. We need to give them more time to battle-test these stabilizing mechanisms. This is one area where I think the Hong Kong regulators are very open to discussion and to working with the industry to find a way.
It is actually very accessible to have meetings with regulators in Hong Kong.
The Middle East and where to build
Ashton: What do you make of Dubai and the Middle East as an upcoming base for blockchain startups, and of the regulatory environment there?▶ 19:23
Patricia: I am very bullish on the Middle East. From a regulatory perspective, Dubai is extremely open. It set up VARA, the Virtual Asset Regulatory Authority, not very long ago, and it engages closely with the industry. I have many friends and contacts who hold regular roundtables with regulators in Dubai. The regulators are engaging with custodians as well as centralized exchanges, and they already have a number of different license types, so it is a ready-made regime. There's a lot of excitement about setting up in Dubai and also in Abu Dhabi. The entire Gulf region is becoming quite a hub for major talent.
Ashton: If you were starting a web3 company and weren't tied to any location, where would you go?▶ 20:59
Patricia: I would definitely be in Asia or the Middle East, because there is a lot of tailwind in this part of the world, and a lot of room for experimentation. It's a very open environment where you feel you can test a lot of things out. When you're starting your own project, you sometimes want to test different ideas, fail fast, work out what to improve and iterate on the product. I think this is the best place to do it, with that level of engagement with regulators and the industry.
This interview has been edited for length and clarity. Recorded November 2023.

