Key takeaways
- Web3 gaming represents a natural evolution from players investing time in games to wanting actual ownership of their digital assets and characters.
- Smart contracts function similarly to game worlds with rule sets, while NFTs parallel in-game assets, creating technical alignment between blockchain and gaming.
- A breakout hit game using blockchain elements could trigger mainstream adoption, similar to ChatGPT's effect, prompting major studios to activate Web3 plans.
- Game developers can maintain profitability in Web3 models while offering player agency through decentralization and external marketplaces for asset trading.
- In-game cosmetics like skins already generate substantial revenue in Web2 games, making the transition to tradeable NFTs a logical extension of existing player spending behavior.
Why games and blockchains fit
Ashton Addison: Why do games and blockchains fit together so naturally?▶ 02:06
Brian D. Evans: Take Ethereum. The smart contract is very similar to a game world: it has a set of rules, and you can do things within that world. The gold in the game is very much like ether, and NFTs are very much like in-game assets. There are all these similarities, and it just makes sense.
Ashton: Why does asset ownership matter to players now?▶ 03:02
Brian: Games have evolved from Mario Brothers, where you played, died and it was game over, to games that go on forever, and then to MMORPGs and Call of Duty, where you play with friends around the world in realistic 3D environments. You invest so much time and energy, but you can't do anything with your character if you stop playing. You're not allowed to sell it, they'll ban the account, and gold selling is highly criticized. The counterargument against web 3 gaming is that nobody wants to own anything. But no one is out there saying, 'I hope Blizzard makes an extra 100 million this year,' either. It's a natural evolution of player agency. People spend so much time customizing their characters that they want to own the assets.
Play to earn showed what was possible with web 3 gaming, but in the end it came across as gimmicky
What play-to-earn got wrong
Ashton: Players already spend heavily on in-game purchases. Why did play-to-earn leave such a bad taste?▶ 07:32
Brian: There are different archetypes of players. Some play for escapism. They need a break from their job or their regular life. With play-to-earn, you see those dollar signs and tokens, and you're pulled out of the game reality and back into the real world. Play to earn showed what was possible with web 3 gaming, but in the end it came across as gimmicky to a lot of outsiders and left a bad taste with the mainstream. At least it showed there was interest and that it's a viable space.
Ashton: If earning becomes the point, the game suffers. How do you find the balance?▶ 10:21
Brian: It's a tough topic because game economies are immensely complicated, and when you introduce a lot of players, things can change, so you need to stay on top of it. It's like running a country's economy. You have to account for inflation and for the math behind how rare certain items are. It's a different beast from game mechanics like attacking with swords. We're starting to see really smart people come into the space. Games take a long time to build, especially when web 3 makes the economies more complex, so it will take time. We're working on a game ourselves, and building a high-quality game and getting the economy right is very complicated.
The barriers: infrastructure and keys
Ashton: What is still holding web 3 gaming back?▶ 13:37
Brian: I don't think the code has been completely cracked yet. We're still working out what creates that ChatGPT effect. Is it the NFTs, the tokens, the economics, the ownership, or just a really good game? We also still have centralization problems, like the iOS App Store, where you can't have an app with crypto in it. Sooner or later we'll have our Steam of web 3: decentralized or web 3-native systems and apps where you can run games and build on top. Right now, games basically have to start from scratch and build everything, and it will be easier once infrastructure-level services exist. Terminology is a problem too. NFTs got demolished in the last cycle and the bear market, and scams gave them a bad name. But that's just terminology. The technology itself is brilliant.
Ashton: What about the user-experience problem of self-custody?▶ 18:37
Brian: One of the biggest problems, as one of the main Gala Games guys said, is that people lose their seed phrase and get locked out of their accounts. The technology is there, but it's a little too hard for people. Vitalik and others have been working on storing keys better and on backup methods, like using your friends. Maybe the answer is a web 2.5 world where two-factor authentication is enough and assets are stored semi-centralized, even though I hate to say that. You could use the NFTs and tokens to get a taste, and take them to a wallet if you want, but you're not forced to. Once the code is cracked on that, it's an easier transition for web 2 players, because they won't be so worried about losing assets or having them hacked or stolen.
If you're building games right now, you'd be shooting yourself in the foot not to look at web 3 elements.
What could trigger mainstream adoption
Ashton: How do the big, traditional studios get involved?▶ 04:47
Brian: We're seeing huge adoption in parts of Asia, and blockchain gaming alliances are even being formed with some big players. I have friends at various web 3 game studios and they all have plans. One possibility is a ChatGPT effect: a smash-hit breakout game gets millions of players overnight and uses blockchain elements. That doesn't mean it has crypto in the app, since that's still blocked on app stores. Then all the studios go, 'Now we've got to make our move, we've got our web 3 plan ready,' and everyone shifts. I firmly believe there's a model where everyone is happy and studios still make a lot of money. Over time they could work toward decentralization, because I've played games that lose developer support and then you can't play anymore.
Ashton: What needs to happen as we move into 2024 and 2025?▶ 24:57
Brian: It's a combination of everything we've talked about. People were fed up with low-quality games, but it takes a long time and a lot of money to build AAA games. It's also about having the right tools to support a World of Warcraft-size player base that isn't going to lose its keys, and about awareness and education. If one or two smash-hit games come out with millions of players overnight, other companies will get on board. I think 2024 and 2025 will be very strong. Interest died down over the last six months and has been creeping back up. If you're building games right now, you'd be shooting yourself in the foot not to look at web 3 elements. Web 2 games will be the DVDs of the world, and web 3 is digital. We'll have that Netflix moment.
This interview has been edited for length and clarity. Recorded November 2023.

