Chris O'Brien / Venable LLP

Chris O'Brien on crypto compliance and regulatory engagement in 2026

InterviewApril 27, 202642:41

In this episode

Chris O’Brien, Partner and Head of the Crypto Practice at Venable LLP, joins Ashton Addison (Crypto Coin Show) for a practical, high-level conversation on what’s changing in US crypto regulation and what that means for builders in 2026. We cover how Web3 companies can engage with regulators without freezing innovation, the most common misconceptions founders have about “being compliant,” and the habits teams can build to reduce legal and enforcement risk as they scale.

We also dig into what’s happening in DC right now on market structure and stablecoin legislation, including the Clarity Act and other proposals, plus the real-world scenarios if major legislation does not pass. Finally, Chris shares a grounded take on AI in legal work and why “ask ChatGPT first” can create serious pitfalls around confidentiality, missing context, and false confidence.

Key takeaways
  • Regulatory clarity is beneficial for business growth, and crypto industry participants now recognize that clear rules enable compliance and business thriving.
  • The Trump administration has shifted away from crypto task forces at the SEC and DOJ, but comprehensive market structure legislation like the Clarity Act remains unpassed.
  • The GENIUS Act for stablecoin regulation has passed, with implementing rules still being written under the new administration.
  • Using ChatGPT for legal advice creates serious risks around confidentiality, missing context, and false confidence in crypto compliance matters.
  • Crypto winters typically last about 18 months and have historically not prevented long-term industry growth despite creating winners and losers.

Chapters

Read the interview

Venable's Chris O'Brien on a third crypto winter and an SEC that is talking again

Chris O'Brien, partner and head of the crypto practice at Venable LLP, has advised on crypto since 2016. In this April 2026 conversation he covers what the 2025 regulatory wave delivered and what it did not, how founders should work with the SEC, why AI should not structure your company, and the Bitzlato case. Comments on the market and legislation reflect the state of play at the time of recording.

Three crypto winters and the 2025 regulatory scorecard

Ashton: What is your background in crypto and law, and how do the two come together? 00:44

Chris O'Brien: I've been practicing law for about 35 years, and I started in crypto in 2016, which for big law is a long time. There weren't many big law lawyers doing this then. We've done just about everything in crypto except ICOs, which we stayed away from because we knew they would run into legal issues with the SEC and the courts. We've represented issuers, early-stage advisors and a lot of investors, and we were involved in the FTX, Celsius and Terra bankruptcies. I've probably done more crypto work in Hollywood than any lawyer I know, because a lot of our Los Angeles practice centers on entertainment and media. We've also been in DC working on regulation like the Clarity Act, and in front of the Trump administration with clients.

Ashton: What were the most important legal developments of 2025, and what do they mean for startups and institutions? 05:49

Chris O'Brien: After the last election we were tremendously optimistic, because it was clear President Trump's administration would be pro-crypto, and there's bipartisan support in Congress. Democrats lean toward consumer protection and Republicans toward financial innovation and freedom, as you'd expect. We saw the GENIUS Act come through to regulate stablecoins, and we're waiting for the rules to be written under it. We've also seen a different approach to investigations and prosecutions. Gone are the days of the crypto task forces at the SEC and the Department of Justice. But we haven't seen the market structure bill, whether it's the Clarity Act or another one. Nothing has been passed or signed that would give us a clear, overarching structure that would last beyond the current administration, and that's disappointing. Regulatory clarity is good for business. It's good when you know the rules of the road and can prove you complied with them. I think the lack of it has something to do with why we're in a crypto winter now.

Read the full interview →

Transcript

Read the full transcript 6,584 words, auto-generated and lightly edited

I'm Ashen Addison from the Crypto Coin Show, and today on Blockchain Interviews have Christopher O'Brien, the head of crypto at Venable LLP, here to talk about crypto and law, regulation, the industry, and how it's moving forward, and the do's and don'ts of startups in crypto, artificial intelligence, and so much more. Chris, welcome to the show, and

thanks for taking the time. Thank you so much for having me. It's a pleasure. Yeah, it's an exciting time in crypto, growing alongside the regulation, and of course there's a lot of legal matters as bigger companies get involved in crypto as well, as startups. Most important, probably setting up your practice properly from the legal side when you're starting up and raising

capital, and you've been in this for a while. I would love to start out by hearing a little bit of your experience and your background in crypto and law, and how those two merge together. Yeah, and again, thank you for having me. So, I've been practicing law for about 35 years, and I started in crypto in 2016, so 10 years ago, which for big law

is a long time. There weren't that many big law lawyers who were doing this in 2016. And it's still a young industry. So, that's actually a lot of the a lot of the lifespan of the of the industry if you think about it. So, I've seen a lot. I think we're into a crypto winter here, which would be my third crypto winter. It's not the end of the world. These

things tend to pass in about 18 months. And the general trendline of the industry goes up over over time. So, I don't think it's time to panic, but there certainly be winners and losers in crypto winter like they're like they're always are. We've done just about everything in crypto with the exception of ICOs. We did not do ICOs because we knew that those were going to run into

legal issues with the SEC and the courts, which they did. So, we specifically stayed away from those. But, we've represented issuers, we've represented early-stage advisors in that phase. We have represented a lot of investors. I don't know how many times I've talked about the Howey test with clients and potential clients and regulatory issues.

we were involved in the bankruptcies FTX, Celsius, Terra in '22, '23. I've done probably more work in Hollywood on crypto than any lawyer I know. There may be somebody out there and I just don't know them, but a lot of our practice at Venable in Los Angeles is centered around entertainment media, and I have a an M&A corporate practice in entertainment media, and those

things have sort of come together around crypto, particularly in the talent side, representing all of the town. But, we've we've also been in DC working on the regulation and the things like the Clarity Act and the bills that are trying to go through right now. Been in front of the Trump administration with clients. So, it's a very broad practice within

crypto and a and a long practice by industry standards. Definitely. Across the spectrum, coast to coast, being involved. Good good call skipping out on the ICO part. I can imagine being a Hollywood lawyer, some of these big names and celebrities have have gotten involved with crypto projects, whether it's creating their own token and

blockchain project or just associating with one. I can imagine them your communications with them and trying to make sure that, you know, they have a huge reputation, they have an empire of wealth already, making sure that's protected on the legal side. Yeah, that's right. It's They're Those are a lot of the concerns. Over time.

Hold on a sec, Chris. It just It cut out. Just start your question again. From there. I just like I can imagine that, you know, there's a lot of legal issues on that on the Hollywood side. Yeah, you're you're absolutely right. Reputational issues are important. And I would say the receptivity of folks in the industry has has waxed and waned with the industry. You

know, when you see a lot of celebrities getting sued as they did with FTX. Tom Brady and others. So, I think Tom's still involved in that litigation. Nobody wants to see that. Nobody on the talent side. But it's also an interesting technology. There's been opportunities for people to be rewarded in the space. It's sort of across the board. I think

personally, I think there's promise for crypto to disaggregate the space between people who are interested in celebrities and celebrities. Disintermediating that in a way that can be rewarding for people. Mhm. We're not seeing it, really. I'm not aware of the company that's trying to do that. I'm sure there are some out there. And maybe that's in the next phase

of crypto. I don't think anybody's unlocked that door yet, but I'm I think it'll happen. Yeah, I have talked to a few out of our 1,500 interviews, a couple that are working with celebrities closely. And but I don't think anyone has the magic key yet that's really taken off to be, you know, a multi-billion dollar empire, but I'm sure it will happen.

You know, throughout 2025, it was a huge year for regulation in the crypto industry and in part due to the admit the new administration more green-lighted. Can you talk about the sort of the most important things that came out of 2025 that relate to the legal side for crypto and what that means for crypto startups and also established institutional and enterprise

companies coming into crypto? Sure. I think after the last election cycle, we were all tremendously optimistic about the potential for what could come out of Washington, D.C. for the industry for crypto industry because we had seen this war on crypto in the prior administration and it was clear that President Trump and his administration were going to be pro-crypto. And there's

a lot of bipartisan support in the Congress. There is a lot of bipartisan support in the Congress on the Democratic side as well as the Republican side. Not exactly, you know, different priorities in some ways. The Democrats are going to be leaning towards consumer protections and Republicans are more about financial innovation and freedoms just as you'd

expect based on their ideologies. And we saw some great things. We saw the GENIUS Act come through the regulation of stablecoins, right? And we're waiting for rules that are going to be read written under the GENIUS Act. And then you know, we've also seen a different approach to investigations and prosecutions by the Trump administration

in the industry. Gone are the days of the crypto task forces at the SEC and the Department of Justice. On the other hand, we haven't seen the market structure bill that we've been hoping to see. Whether it was the Clarity Act or one of the other bills to come through the Congress or through the Senate. Obviously, nothing's been passed and nothing's been signed yet that would

give us a very clear overarching regulatory structure that presumably would last beyond the current administration. We haven't seen that yet. And that's disappointing for the industry. I think people came around to the point of view finally, which we were talking about for years, that regulatory clarity is a good thing. It's good for business. Right? It's good when you know the rules

of the road and you can comply with them and prove that you complied with them. Look at the biggest businesses in the world, they're generally complying with law that is fairly clear and well-settled, and they're happy to do so. Business thrives within that environment. I think crypto wants to be there now in the United States, and we're just not getting it yet out of

the political process. So, it's it's a mixed bag, and I do think that lack of regulatory clarity long-term has something to do with why we're in a crypto winter now. Yeah. Yeah, I think it I agree, it's it's disappointing, and I think the retail traders were just hoping, you know, market regulation overall would be pushed through, and the prices would go through the roof, and

all the people that believed in crypto early would be prosperous, and, you know, it's it's been pretty disappointing to see at least the price of Bitcoin relative to where when the administration started to where it is now, you know, where it's actually down. Yeah. It's It is disappointing, not predicted. I didn't hear anybody really saying, "Oh, in a year, we'll

sort of be in MLA's in the industry and prices will be down like this." It's not the end of the world. You know, at the bottom of the first crypto winter that I went through in 2018, the price of Bitcoin was four thousand dollars. Yeah. We never got back down after the first crypto winter was over to where it was at the peak before the first crypto winter.

Somebody could check me on this, but it was 20. You know, Bitcoin was at 20 and everybody was doing dances and then it went down to four. 20 seems unimaginable now, right? So, if you take a longer term view, I think I think it's still pretty pretty optimistic, but you know, history doesn't repeat itself, but it does rhyme, you know, according to Mark Twain.

this is an interesting period because there wasn't a huge catalyst for this fall, right? You can't point to a single event. There was no FTX bankruptcy that made this happen. There was no geopolitical event that appears to have made this happen. It looks like you've seen a lot of Wall Street investors going out of ETFs, right? During this downturn. A lot of

the trading is big traders and big holders of positions moving with markets, maybe moving with external uncertainties in the geopolitical situation and in markets generally. It is disappointing, but it's not forever, you know. The good times and the bad times all pass away. So, if you're in it for the long term, you know, you're in it for the long

term. Definitely. I think anybody who comes into crypto thinking they're going to it's going to be the vehicle that gets them rich overnight is dreaming, you know, and there's a lot of benefit to the technology and the valuations of that as it grows and doesn't adopt to the world overnight. That takes time and the valuations should be in line

with that as it slowly works through with companies that say Web3 companies that Venable's working with and they want to do something very innovative with the current regulation how it is with Clarity Act, for example, still in the works and the only thing really in it is the genius, you know, how do you how do you advise companies to like walk that line when they're trying

to do something innovative, but it's sort of in the gray area? There's a lot of good news with the change in the administration, and one of the best pieces of news is that the SEC is talking to entrepreneurs again in the crypto space. Right? They're writing no-action letters. A no-action letter is the viewpoint of the staff, so it's not the same thing as a

law that was passed. It's not the same thing as a judge writing an opinion in a court case, but it's the view of the staff that some legal conclusion is what they currently think is the right [snorts] interpretation of the law. And during the Biden administration they pretty much closed the window and stopped doing no-action letters in crypto. And they pretty much told everybody that

they were doing that. So, there really wasn't an open lane for an entrepreneur with their law firm to go and talk to the SEC and say "You know, it could be this way, it could be that way. We think it's that way. Do you agree with us?" And get some clarity from the staff at least on their current thinking. And there's real value in being able to get that. It's not the same thing as

having a law. It's not the same thing as getting a decision out of a judge. But being able to take an innovative project, have a conversation with the SEC and have them express their views is something real. We also have a have a lot less trepidation about regulation by enforcement now than we did in the last administration. There are just fewer of

those cases going on and it just doesn't appear to be the current administration's point of view. They're still going to go after fraud. They're still going to go after crime. We expect that. But an entrepreneur who in good faith, with good legal counsel, who's going to have a discussion with the administration, whether that's through the SEC or the CFTC or some other

regulatory body, is you know, going to have a lot more comfort in what they're doing than they did even, you know, a year and a half ago. So that's that's a better world for us. It's not the same thing as having a market structure bill with rules that are passed through regulators and, you know, ideally years of decision making behind it, which is

what you have in the securities world. And a lot of other regulatory worlds. But it's But it's it's much better than where it was. And all I can say is, you know, take it step by step. Don't don't be scared off necessarily that there isn't the market structure bill and say I can't do something that I think is innovative and I want to do. We have a lot more hope to get to an answer

that we feel pretty good about today than we did even a year ago. It's nice that the communication channels are open and, you know, you're not blocking off the amazing ideas that crypto and blockchain entrepreneurs are having, especially with AI now to be able to build build faster and push things into production faster than ever. It the

innovation that can come out of the US if, you know, that communication those channels are open and they're not just blocked from exploring new ideas, I think, can bring a lot of wealth and prosperity to this country. I mean, AI is potentially transformative in I mean, you name it. Almost everything except bricklaying. You know, it things that are done by hand,

but I'm sure somebody will tell me it is going to transform bricklaying in some in some way. Certainly in this industry, and we'll see where, you know, we'll we'll see where it goes. It's not even the middle of the first inning, I think, Mhm. AI.

Definitely. But to your point, it will supercharge development projects, I think. Mhm. Definitely.



Take your pick. Anything that runs on software is going to be is going to be supercharged in the development process with AI. And this has always been the industry's promise, I think. If we had a regulatory structure, if we had a at least a neutral, if not a favorable administrative approach, then the flowers are going to bloom, right? The solutions that are based on

Crypto and blockchain are going to manifest themselves. People are going to experiment. They're going to succeed in some of the experiments. We're not quite there on the regulatory side, but we're in a lot better place than we were and you know, this I think is the opportunity to prove that the tech has the value that people have believed it had for

going on well, it's over a decade now. Mhm. If you were in a lineup for coffee and you had a very short amount of time and there was a crypto startup founder behind you and he was like, "Give me a quick legal do's and don'ts as I'm starting my company, you know, what tidbits can you give me to and to make sure that I'm doing right and what I definitely shouldn't

do?" Well, I could probably do it in a shorter period of time than that depending on you know, how quick the line was if you pre-ordered or you're actually waiting. One thing I would say is get good legal advice. Right? Like get good legal advice and don't assume that legal stuff is either unimportant or just complicated BS because it's not.

You can talk to go talk to Sam Bankman-Fried and ask him if he thinks he should have spent more time on the legal side of his business and his his affairs. Dramatic example, right? But get good qualified ad advice, which is not necessarily you know, a layup to figure that out. Mhm. There are sorry.

There are people who've been in the industry for a long time giving legal advice who that doesn't necessarily mean they've given good legal advice. And no, I'm not going to name names. But find somebody who's going to align with you on doing it right doing it efficiently, of course, doing it right, but paying attention to things that matter because there are

landmines in the road that you want to avoid. You know, mundane things. Getting your structure right from a tax perspective could be a multi-million dollar issue. Mhm. Deciding where you are and are not going to be exposed from a legal perspective. Are you going to do business in the United States? Are you not going to do business in the United

States? Which jurisdictions are you going to avoid in terms of your customers and your operations? It's a it's a rich topic, so get get good advice and take some time to figure that out. Don't necessarily just use your brother-in-law because he's got a lot of great Definitely. Or I'm guessing don't use ChatGPT would be on the don't list if as your main

source of advice. You know, chat I can't speak to ChatGPT, but I've done We're we're we're seriously using AI in our practice when we have consent from our clients. We are using closed systems, not the open systems. Mhm. And I'm very careful about confiden- confidentiality and things like that. But, to the extent that I've been road

testing it and I'm impressed more than I'm unimpressed. Mhm. But I would definitely want a human lawyer to be on top of any of the results and any of the any of the questions that you're coming up with. Mhm. And discrete things can feel really good. Processes don't feel to me like they're all that good. I saw

journalist on a reel talking about how he had fed a contract into I think it was chat GPT and got comments back and they redlined the document for him and wrote a cover letter and sent it to the other side. And the other side said, "Yeah, we agree with you. We'll take all of these comments." So, he was very happy he didn't pay a lawyer to go through that

process. Then I thought to myself, "What about the issue that AI didn't pick up? That a lawyer who's been practicing for 30 years would pick up. What about that one that you missed? What about when the other side comes back and says, "Yes to issues number one, two, and three, but no to issues four, five, and six." Is chat GPT going to negotiate that for

you? Is it Is there a good medium distance solution for you? Is chat GPT going to go to court and cross-examine a witness? It's not. So, like every technology, there's a promises and limitations. Yeah, I would not set up my company using an online you know, whatever it was before

AI or any of the AI to do that. Things are just too complicated. And at this stage, it's not ready to AI's a very fast growing adolescent at this point. Don't don't let a fast growing adolescent do the blueprints for your house. Don't let a fast growing adolescent AI structure your company either would be

my advice. Yeah. That's That's probably good advice. You know, you don't want to end up like like SBF or any of these other people that are that are on the wrong side of the law one way or another in crypto.

One thing I would say Ashton to clients is we're expensive, but we're really cheap compared to doing it wrong. Mhm. I like any lawyer who's been around

for a long time have spent a lot of hours and unfortunately a lot of client money undoing things that unqualified lawyers did. Mhm. Fixing situations that either didn't have good lawyering or didn't have any lawyering, people did on their own. And that can be really expensive. Much more expensive than doing it right in the first place.

Definitely. So you know, hopefully that's advice that the guy in the coffee line will take before he finishes his his latte. For sure. You know, you mentioned mentioned SBF. CZ was also an interesting case being in there and then I guess being being pardoned for one reason or another or doing his four months. And then there's this Bitzlato case which I

know you're quite familiar with. Can you give a little bit of context into that? Sure. So, we represent Anatoly Legkodymov who's the founder of Bitzlato. So, he's a client of ours to be very clear. Oh, and one thing I should say Ashton, I'm not giving anybody legal advice on this on this podcast. Somebody wants that, they can contact me. We'll be happy to talk

about an engagement, but it's standard. These are just my opinions Definitely.

that I'm giving. I'm not giving anybody legal advice. So, Anatoly is First of all, he's a wonderful guy. He's the furthest thing from a Russian thug that you could imagine. Mhm. He's an intellectual. He's a software engineer. He worked in Silicon Valley for a couple

of years. He's an inventor. Just before [clears throat] I get into the substance of his case, while he's been in a lockup, he's on an ice hole, he's in an ice facility right now. He invented a cold weather mask where you can work or do sports in sub-zero temperatures. And we filed the patent on it. He did it without a computer or without any rendering materials. And

it's manufactured as a matter of fact, I think I have one of the want to see it. I have one of the prototypes over there. So he's a remarkable guy. He's started this crypto exchange. I want to say in 2017, 16, so early days. Wrote the software himself. And he really wasn't even planning on making money with the exchange. He was just interested in the technology and

wanted to give people a fast and inexpensive way to do financial transactions. The exchange was almost entirely aimed at the Russian market. He's Russian, was almost entirely aimed at the Russian market. And it was successful, but it's nothing like Binance or the big exchanges. They never They never did that. Most people have never heard of the exchange.

I hadn't Frankly, I hadn't heard of it before he called us up to represent him. So, what happened with Anatoly? Completely almost completely unrelated to his exchange, Bitslato. There was a dark web company called Hydra that was operating on the dark web for some years. And it appears to be mostly a place where Russians went to buy and

sell drugs. And people did illicit I think assumed mostly illicit activities. By the way, if you want to hide, don't call your site Hydra. That's a really bad name. It sounds like it's something out of a James Bond movie, right? But our client had nothing to do with Hydra. They never met anybody from Hydra. He never had any interactions with

them. Those activities were going off over there. He had a crypto exchange or peer-to-peer crypto exchange. But then at some point in 21 maybe, I want to say, Chainalysis came out with a report and said that a large percentage of transactions on the Bitslato exchange were either funds taking funds off of that exchange, going doing something on

Hydra, or doing something on Hydra and the funds were coming back into accounts in the Bitslato exchange. Mhm. Not company transactions, customer transactions. People coming on and, you know, they had their own accounts. The company wasn't wasn't doing transactions with the Hydra exchange. The US authorities and the French authorities shut down the Hydra

exchange. Which was sort of I think a non-event for Anatoly and his exchange. At least in terms of, you know, how it affected them. And then Anatoly came to the United States on vacation. And with his family. He's got young kids. They were in Florida. And he got arrested. And he was charged with a single count of running an unlicensed money

transmission business. A little bit technical here, but if you move money or gold or anything else of value as a business in the United States, that's called a money transmission business. And you need a license, a federal [snorts] license and a license from every state. People should know that, like crypto people should know that because crypto is moving a thing of value.

So he was charged with a single count of running an unlicensed money transmission business in the United States. Which I think was shocking to him because he didn't allow US people to use his exchange. So if you try to go on to their exchange and set up an account and you gave them a US passport, they would say, "Sorry, you can't sign up. We don't allow US people on the

exchange." it turns out that only about $31,000 ever moved into or out of the United States from the exchange. And we believe that in every case it was probably a person who had faked their identity or their location. Nonetheless, he was charged. And the Biden administration's interpretation of this

section was $1 is enough for jurisdiction. So $1 makes you a money transmission business in the United States. And knowledge that somebody was going to or from your exchange into a dark website was enough as well. So you didn't actually have to be involved in the Hydra activity as long as you had knowledge of what customers were doing so and they pointed to the chain

analysis report as the knowledge under the statute. So very broad statute, very broadly interpreted. Mhm. And you know, rather than face a lot more accusations and a lot more potential years, he pled guilty properly, Greg pled guilty under that single

code violation or criminal violation. And the judge sentenced him to time served. So, he was in the worst jail in America in Brooklyn for 18 months. And the judge heard the facts and said, "Time served. You're free to go." which is not nothing. He was in He was in jail for 18 months. But they took him into an ICE facility because his visa had run out.

Because he was in Wackenhut during that period of time. And in the meantime the French government who had promised us his legal team that he would not be prosecuted under French law if he gave them an interview because they had other folks from his exchange in custody and were prosecuting them that they wouldn't prosecute him filed an arrest warrant

for him to go to France and face additional charges on the same conduct. And that's where the case is today. So, he's in a he's in a federal ICE facility. The French government is asking for him to be extradited France to face charges now. Despite the fact that they agreed with us that they wouldn't do that. Despite the fact that they're clearly

going to use his interview against him, which he couldn't do in the United States. That would be self-incrimination. And we're waiting for a judge to make a decision on that hearing on that motion to move him. And at the same time hoping that the Trump administration will stop that from happening. And potentially grant him a pardon on the basis that

He's served his time. He's got a long useful life ahead of him as an inventor and an entrepreneur. And ideally, that would happen in the United States. Mhm. Long answer. I'm sorry, Ashton. There's a lot in there, but

it's a it's a huge story and sort of reminds me of the Silk Road, you know, at least there was a market, but in this case, it

was an exchange that, you know, was unrelated to it. But, you know, those people get their funds from somewhere, but it goes back to that like, you have software you can't control you can't be liable for whatever people are, you know, using the It's like It's like if you go to the bank and you deposit illicit funds, can you charge the bank because they're

holding it if they didn't know where it was from? You know, there's there's so many faucets.

Yeah, exactly. I mean, every bank knows that they have customers Mhm. who take money out of their bank or put money into their bank from illicit activities. They just don't know exactly who it is and they don't know exactly, what the activities were. And they

don't get charged Mhm. for that reason because they don't have knowledge of it. Most of those are money transmission businesses, so they wouldn't be charged under this, but they're not they're not charged as accessories to crimes either. There's a lesson in there for crypto entrepreneurs to make sure that you're doing KYC AML very well.

Regulators have focused on that aspect of these early stage companies, but KYC AML doesn't eliminate this problem either. Mhm. You can get knowledge about your Oh, did we lose Did I lose you for a second? Yeah, you're back now. Okay. You can do perfect KYC AML. That's

not going to mean that you never have people doing illicit things with the money that's passing through your custody, right?

Mhm. There is no perfect way to make that happen. And this statute is very broad and it's very open to prosecutorial discretion. And but the US case he

was fully litigated. The Justice Department with all of their resources, the FBI with all of its resources, was on the other side of our case. And the judge, who's been on the bench I think for 30 years or something like that, heard all the facts and said, "Time served." Said 18 months time served. Our client served his time. He's fully served his time. He spent another year

in the nice cold on top of his time. He hasn't been free to be with his family for must be going on 3 years now. He served his time. The idea that the French government needs to come in now on the same facts and subject him to another 20 years potentially of punishment when a US judge, prompted by the Justice Department and the FBI, came to the conclusion that 18 months

time served was enough, is just very hard to swallow. It feels like an injustice. We have a system. He went through the system. He served his time. Where does this end? Does Spain come in after France? Does Ecuador come in after Spain? Does Canada come in after Ecuador? I mean, come on. At some point people serve their

time and it should end. And that time is now in my opinion. For sure. Yeah, you know, I recalling my undergrad studying law, there was like some double double jeopardy, you know, you can't be charged. But if he goes to another country, then, you know, hands are hands are off, I guess. Unfortunately, the issues are very complicated

and the government is making its its arguments. But one of the frustrating things about this is I think if somebody at the top of the Trump administration paid attention to this, they would realize that this prosecution was part of the Biden war on crypto. Mhm. And say, "Okay, they prosecuted this, they got the sentence out of the judge, he served his

sentence. Why would we, as the Trump administration,

[clears throat]

now continue with conveyer belts to bring him to France to be prosecuted yet again on the same circumstances? Mhm. That's a Biden war on crypto initiative. Why is the Trump administration, why would the Trump administration continue that kind of behavior when it's totally inconsistent

with the approach that the industry's taking towards crypto? This is a very very talented guy who would love to stay in the United States or go home to Russia. But he'd love to stay in the United States to do his next venture. He's got many decades of a useful life here. He's a young father. And it's it's it's hard for me to believe

that if somebody were to actually focus on this at a high enough level in the administration, whether that was Secretary Rubio or somebody in the White House that they wouldn't conclude as I do that the right thing is to say no to the extradition. And ideally allow this guy to stay in the United States so that he can do his next thing, but at the very least let

him go home. Let him go home to his family. You know, enough is enough particularly in these facts and circumstances. Definitely. Yeah, I appreciate you sharing that Chris. It's it's a very interesting story and yeah, there's been a lot of wounds from the from the Biden administration that have bled through and some of things have been

fixed and some haven't with the Trump administration. So, let's hope that moving forward the industry and cleans up all the all the loose ends and brings justice to the unjust things that happened with all of the not just BitMEX but all of the crypto companies that I've spoken to that have had their backs against the wall with you know, start trying to do

startups and all these other parts of crypto that we've talked about today that you know, they don't have to go through those issues anymore as more market structure and more clarity in general comes into the industry. Yeah, I mean, unless you just think crypto should be shut down, which I don't, but people in the Biden administration obviously did. Right?

There were people clearly people who believed that in power within the Biden administration.

[clears throat]

but it that day is past. Right? We're not we're not living in that view of the world anymore from the administration. So, [clears throat] and you know, look, everybody's got their business. They're [snorts] focused on their thing that they're doing,

right? And I appreciate that and I understand that. I think Anatoly's case is one where I'm hoping somebody in the administration or somebody in the industry will pay attention to this and say, "Hey, look. This is the right thing to do. I'll take my attention away from my little thing for 1 minute and say, this would be wrong for him to go to France and face 20

years for the same conduct. Why would the United States do that? This is If we're If we're no longer doing the Biden war on crypto, we shouldn't do this. Mhm. Take Take a minute to do the right thing. Mhm. I'm wishing the best for Venable and for Anatoly and solving that. And I appreciate your insights today on everything. It's It's a

complex world. The legal industry, especially in crypto, and innovative sectors the most out of any. And now with in AI coming in, things are moving faster than ever. So, it's definitely a time to be paying attention. I appreciate

Mhm. And hopefully be optimistic. optimistic. Better days are coming. It feels cold out there at the moment,

but as I said, these things usually last 18 months or so, and then and then it gets better, right? So, let's be optimistic. Hope that innovation will flower in this administration. Hope we will get to a market structure bill in the United States. And if not, then at least we'll get to regulatory clarity from the administration. And I you know, I

think the path keeps going up. Definitely. What's the best way to learn more about what people should do and what Venable can help with and to follow along with any of the other insights that you've brought today. Remarkably easy to find. Do a Google search. Put my name and Venable into any any search engine, and you'll find me. I

think my phone number is on there, but certainly my email address is on there. People can reach out to me and talk about substance things for sure. Very easy. Sounds great, Chris. Thank you so much for taking the time. All the best with everything. Thanks for pushing the industry forward more, and we'd love to follow up again in the near future.

Thanks, Ashton. I really appreciate you.

Related coverage

More interviews

Browse all 1,089 interviews

Get new interviews firstCCS Insider, the free newsletter from Ashton Addison. Twice a week.