Key takeaways
- BlockApps pivoted from private enterprise blockchains to public blockchain RWA tokenization after observing major companies like BlackRock moving toward public chains.
- The company's core thesis focuses on democratizing high-value assets like art, real estate, and collectibles through fractional ownership and blockchain-based trading.
- BlockApps developed StratMera, an Ethereum-derived blockchain with enhanced features for identity, consensus, and smart contract modeling to support RWA use cases.
- Blockchain's primary value for real-world assets is separating ownership from possession, enabling faster trading and lower costs without physical asset movement.
- Early RWA adoption targets assets people already understand and want access to, including metals, collectibles, and commercial real estate rather than speculative tokens.
From private enterprise chains to public blockchains
Ashton Addison: How did your background lead to BlockApps and its focus on real-world assets?▶ 00:21
Victor Wong: I've been a long-time participant in the space. I helped with the launch of the Ethereum public blockchain, and from there we focused on real-world adoption through private blockchains and enterprise customers. We built many of the first blockchain applications used by enterprises, using Ethereum technology. More recently, we realized that mainstream adoption is not going to come primarily through private blockchains but through public ones. Enterprises are now getting comfortable putting some of their workloads on public blockchains. The BlackRock announcement this week is an example. We saw that trend over a year ago and made the pivot toward real-world assets (RWAs).
Ashton: What did your enterprise work teach you, and what is BlockApps' mission now?▶ 02:50
Victor: For Fortune 500 companies and governments, we took real-world assets and tokenized them, mostly for supply chain use cases. We started with basic Ethereum but had to add features to make it work, including identity, changes to the consensus algorithm, and ways to model assets in smart contracts. Our mission now is to onboard the next billion blockchain users by offering rare and valuable things. It has to be something someone would buy whether or not blockchain was involved. Then you use the blockchain to make it more enticing, through lower cost from fractionalizing or through secondary market trading. To do that, we launched our own Ethereum-derived blockchain with these extra features.
The core function of blockchains for real-world assets is to separate ownership from possession.
Which assets come first, and why ownership is not possession
Ashton: Which types of assets are best suited to early tokenization?▶ 04:44
Victor: The earliest RWAs were stablecoins. What we think about is things people can understand and want access to. There are whole classes of assets we want to democratize that normal people don't have access to. Say you wanted to buy a high-end piece of art or commercial real estate. You probably wouldn't know where to go, and that's assuming you have the money, which most people don't. So we use the blockchain's ability to fractionalize, and to de-risk by letting people sell when they want. We lead with anything the wealthy have in their portfolios that normal people don't. That includes art, commercial real estate and collectibles, and people we talk to are interested in moving in this direction.
Ashton: What is the core benefit of putting real-world assets on a blockchain?▶ 07:54
Victor: I think that's the core piece most people don't talk about. The core function of blockchains for real-world assets is to separate ownership from possession. You don't need to physically hold something to benefit from trading or reselling it. We've already seen this at an industry level. Commodities futures markets do it. In the sneaker market, consignment vendors hold the actual item and you can retrade it without shipping it every time. We're generalizing that. Our ultimate vision is to take any tradable real-world asset and put it on the blockchain, so it can move very fast, be more reliable, and lower the cost of partial ownership without buying the whole thing.
Tokenized silver and the question of control
Ashton: What is different about buying metals as tokens?▶ 09:05
Victor: Metals can be heavy and bulky to ship. A thousand ounces of silver is close to 80 pounds, and the shipping costs alone are enormous. People complain about gas costs, but think about shipping that. To trade without having the physical thing, you first have to trust that it's held and real. So we have issuers, who are verified and hold the physical asset. For the silver we sell today, we work with a partner, Tokeny. You're effectively buying shares in 100-ounce bars kept in a vault. We took that idea from asset-backed stablecoins, which BlackRock is also doing with financial instruments, and applied it to real things.
Ashton: How does buying asset tokens differ from going through the stock market or an ETF?▶ 11:32
Victor: The big difference is control. You can buy ETFs of real estate, art or metals, but you're missing control over what you're buying. You don't decide to buy this building and not that one, or this piece of art and not that one. We offer asset tokens, so you buy a component of the asset itself. If you want to group them into a fund, that's fine with us. I think people will build portfolios themselves once they have that choice. Even real estate in one city or one district can be very different. Then there are management fees, which experts charge a lot for. Our fees are transparent, and we generally don't charge those ongoing fees.
We need to find things that people want to buy regardless of whether they're on the blockchain or not.
The RWA era and making blockchain invisible
Ashton: What does BlackRock's move into this space mean for tokenization?▶ 13:49
Victor: To us it's the icing on the cake of a trend we've seen for a long time. With private blockchains, companies wanted to tokenize real items to track and move them. We tracked agricultural products, oil and energy products, and physical mining resources. There's a huge amount of value in digitizing something and understanding its ownership and where it came from. That doesn't have to be used only by large companies. Individuals can use it to make buying decisions, and I think that's why BlackRock is moving in. It gives us an opportunity to move illiquid assets onto the blockchain. The majority of the world's assets are illiquid, and the stock market is just a small part of what we could tokenize. I think BlackRock is waking up to that too.
Ashton: Why do you think capital is starting to move into this space now?▶ 16:56
Victor: Having been around as long as I have, you see these waves. There was Ethereum's launch, then the ICO boom and a crypto winter, then the NFT boom and another winter. What's driving activity now is the realization that blockchain can be used for asset-backed tokens. When I talk to non-crypto natives about tokens, they always ask what they're actually buying. The honest answer is network computational power or math, and that isn't satisfying to most people. We need to find things that people want to buy regardless of whether they're on the blockchain or not. I think we're moving into the RWA era, with asset-backed stablecoins of all kinds.
Ashton: How would a newcomer buy tokenized assets without learning blockchain?▶ 20:50
Victor: The experience on Ethereum and layer 2s has improved dramatically, so people who know how to use MetaMask can buy our assets directly on the public chain. Starting tomorrow, we're launching carbon-neutral silver that way. The marketplace is meant to provide a Web 2.5 experience for non-blockchain users. You create an identity, pay by credit card and see what you own. Everything you buy is effectively a token, but we hide that. In many ways it looks like a normal website, but under the hood it's all blockchain technology. As people get more comfortable, we want to move them in a more blockchain direction. Our next release will feel more like an NFT marketplace. The average user we're going after still finds it overwhelming, so we have to meet them where they are today.
This interview has been edited for length and clarity. Recorded April 2024.

