Skip to content

The CCS Interview

Why DeFi insurers say audits aren't enough and market manipulation can't be covered

Dan Thomson of InsurAce and Rupert Barksfield of Amulet Protocol explain how their DeFi insurance protocols work, why audits give users false comfort, and where cover stops. The conversation was recorded in November 2022, after a record month for hacks and exploits.

Interview by Ashton Addison Recorded November 2022 4 min read

Key takeaways

  • InsurAce covers 140 different protocols across 20 chains and has paid out 11.7 million for the Curve exploit, the largest payout in DeFi insurance history.
  • Only 25 percent of total assets on-chain are currently insured, creating a significant protection gap compared to traditional finance where insurance is standard.
  • One-third of audited projects fail to implement required security updates recommended by auditors before launch, making audit stamps insufficient for safety assurance.
  • Institutional firms increasingly require smart contract insurance coverage before deploying capital into protocols, making insurance a prerequisite for institutional adoption.
  • October 2023 saw over 700 million dollars siphoned from DeFi smart contracts through hacks and exploits, demonstrating the critical need for insurance protection.

Two approaches to DeFi cover

Ashton Addison: What does InsurAce do, and why does DeFi need insurance?▶ 00:25

Dan Thomson: InsurAce is the first multi-chain insurance protocol in DeFi. We cover about 140 protocols and have covered around $350 million worth of assets. We've also made the largest payout in the history of the space, $11.7 million. There's real demand for this because the space has a huge number of exploits and lost funds. Anyone who has been in crypto long enough has probably lost funds in one way or another, and they'd appreciate some insurance. Our mission is to make the space safer, and to make web3 safer for everyone.

Ashton: What is Amulet doing differently?▶ 02:03

Dan: We operate on Solana, and right now we insure five protocols against smart contract risk. What we do differently is how we manage our staked capital. We stake assets with a validator that generates yield, and we pay claims out of that yield rather than out of the principal staked assets. In our view, more insurance is better than less.

Market manipulation, I don't think, could be an insurable event.

Why audits aren't enough

Ashton: Why do users put so much trust in audits?▶ 04:55

Dan: It's the same in traditional finance. You never think about who audited Citibank or Bank of America when you're using their app. DeFi has that problem now because of the hacks. Auditors come in and give a stamp of approval, but there are good auditors and less good ones, shady ones and really clean ones. That's a difficult marketplace to navigate.

Ashton: Is having an audit enough?▶ 05:47

Dan: Not on its own. A firm we work closely with found that something like a third of projects don't make the required updates after an audit. The auditor finds the issues, but the team doesn't fix them, perhaps because they're under pressure to launch on time. There isn't enough accountability for follow-up, and that puts the onus on users to read the audit and check whether the patches were made. Most people won't do that. They just assume an audit means it's safe, or safer.

Ashton: Who is actually asking for insurance?▶ 08:02

Dan: It isn't only users. Institutional firms want to buy a lot of insurance, and protocols themselves want to work with those institutions. We're working with a protocol that deals with a huge institutional firm. That firm wants to deploy capital into another protocol, and the client says that if you have smart contract insurance in place they'll happily do it, but until then they won't commit a penny. They read the news and understand the risks beyond price risk. Price risk they can handle.

What can and can't be insured

Ashton: October saw record hacks. How can DeFi insurance cover so many different scenarios?▶ 09:15

Dan: Right now, most cover available is for smart contract risk and stablecoin depegs. There's still huge demand for new products, such as rug pulls, bridges, private key loss and NFTs. The biggest problem facing the market is capacity: we're limited by how much we can underwrite. It's not too dissimilar to natural disaster insurance, which is low frequency and high severity, so you can't insure everything. Hacks aren't going to slow down. Projects and investors can do things to be safer, such as bug bounties, audits and extra layers of security. Hacks generate innovation: the bigger ones are usually more creative, and then they don't tend to happen again. The smaller hacks are often simple ones that people haven't patched. The hacks are getting bigger because there's more value in the space, but they're not slowing down builders or demand.

Ashton: Could Amulet have helped with the Mango Markets exploit?▶ 14:42

Dan: Our cover is for smart contract risk, and unless the smart contract is broken, it isn't an insurable event. We had a tiny exposure through our smart contract cover, and we'd have been happy to pay out had there been a smart contract breach. But Mango had posted in its community that manipulating certain smaller assets could let someone make another token and liquidate a whole bunch of contracts, and that's what happened. Everything gets labelled a hack, and this wasn't one. Luna and UST were similar: the risk was well documented in the forums, but it was accepted because it took hundreds of millions of dollars to attack. Market manipulation, I don't think, could be an insurable event. As an industry, we need to wrap packages of insurance together, covering smart contract risk, stablecoin exposure and wallet custodian risk. The trade-off is the cost of the premiums against the yield you're going to make.

Hacks generate innovation: the bigger ones are usually more creative, and then they don't tend to happen again.

Claims and getting started

Ashton: How do claims work in decentralized insurance, and how is that different from traditional insurers?▶ 22:11

Dan: Everything is on chain. Your cover is visible on chain, and if you suffer a loss you submit a claim. The DAO then votes on its validity, and anyone who participates in the vote is rewarded. The process is transparent, with a public claim and a public vote. If required, an expert team also reviews it, and there's an appeals process. When a claim is accepted, the payout goes straight to a nominated wallet. The trade-off is some publicity, because your wallet will be identified as one that held capital in a protocol and got hacked. With our UST depeg payout, the DAO voted that it was a legitimate depeg event, and the entire process was completed in less than a month. With traditional insurers on a high-risk new product, you could still be dealing with it years later.

Ashton: Where should DeFi users start if they want to look into insurance?▶ 26:04

Dan: Visit the protocols' websites, and use aggregators such as Bright Union to compare prices and covers. Do your own research and check the actual policy wording, so you understand what risks you're covered for. Add insurance to your investor checklist. People already check whether there's an audit and whether the team is public or anonymous, and whether the project offers insurance should be on that list too.

This interview has been edited for length and clarity. Recorded November 2022.

Dan Thomson
Dan ThomsonDan Thomson is the founder and CEO of Sensay, an AI company that began with digital replicas of individuals and now focuses on knowledge capture and transfer for organisations. He studied philosophy at King's College London and completed an MBA at the University of Cambridge.… Full profile →
Share this interviewXLinkedIn
▶ Watching the interview