Key takeaways
- Centralized exchanges require users to divulge personal information to governments, while decentralized exchanges keep user information on the blockchain with no central control.
- McAfeeDEX is working on cross-chain atomic swap functionality to enable trading between different cryptocurrencies, expected by end of first quarter or early second quarter.
- McAfeeDEX logic will be deployed across multiple blockchains including Tron, Binance Chain, and Neo, not limited to Ethereum.
- Privacy coins coupled with decentralized exchanges remove government surveillance and control, which governments will likely attempt to ban through legislation.
- Enforcing bans on privacy coins is practically impossible without shutting down the internet, as transactions cannot be detected or tracked.
Why decentralized exchanges
Ashton Addison: As a security expert, would you advise people to stay away from centralized exchanges and use decentralized ones instead? And how does that affect their privacy?▶ 00:22
John McAfee: With a centralized exchange your privacy is exposed, because you have to divulge information. How much that matters depends on how concerned you are about it. In financial affairs especially, governments want to know who, what, when, where and why about any transaction. If you're happy with that risk, that's fine. For those who aren't, decentralized exchanges are the only way to go. Nobody controls them, and they can never be shut down. Our logic is on the blockchain.
Ashton: Decentralized exchanges account for only about 1% of trading volume. What has to happen for that to change?▶ 01:42
John: The reason decentralized exchanges haven't taken off is cross-chain transactions. How do you convert your Bitcoin to Monero, for example? That is the bottleneck, and it's why we're still in beta. We know the solution and we're working on it. It won't be done until the end of the first quarter, perhaps early in the second quarter. Then decentralized exchanges will have exactly the same functionality as centralized ones, without you having to hand over your information and be at the mercy of them freezing your account over possibly illegal activity.
Ashton: Most decentralized exchanges run on Ethereum, which isn't fully anonymous and only lets you trade Ethereum tokens. Is that a major inhibitor?▶ 03:09
John: We started with Ethereum, but that's not what we're counting on. Our logic is going onto every blockchain. We've already added it to Tron, and we're adding more chains, including NEO, before the end of the year. If you're using Ethereum, though, I can't fix the problems in the fundamental architecture of the coins you use. That's not my job. But we will have it on every chain.
It's a stupid law and I'm not obeying it.
Privacy coins versus the state
Ashton: Do you believe governments will start banning privacy coins like Monero?▶ 04:24
John: Of course they're going to ban the coins. Privacy coins coupled with decentralized exchanges remove you from any control and even surveillance from anybody anywhere, and that scares governments. But there is such a thing as civil disobedience. People have practiced it many times, for example by smoking marijuana where it was illegal, even when the penalty was prison. They said, "It's a stupid law and I'm not obeying it." When they ban privacy coins, which protect you from their corruption, you will say the same thing. If you're smoking weed, a dog can come and sniff it out. With privacy coins there is nothing to smell, nothing to see. Tell me how you're going to enforce that law.
Ashton: You could ban Bitcoin and Ethereum, but you can't enforce it unless you turn off the internet. How could anyone prove you're using the coins?▶ 06:49
John: This technology sprang from us. It didn't come from a government agency or a large corporation. It came from ordinary people. Fewer than a dozen bright, geeky, excited technologists gave us the schematics for an entire industry. So yes, we are a threat. But think about privacy coins and distributed exchanges, where nothing can be tracked and no records are kept except the transaction itself. The only recourse governments have is to shut the internet down.
Stablecoins and government digital money
Ashton: What's your view on stablecoins as an interim solution to avoid going back to fiat? Some are backed by very little, and others by commodities still tied to the traditional economy.▶ 10:40
John: Of course we have to have stablecoins. I'm fond of Dai. It never varies more than 1% from the US dollar, up or down, no matter what the volume or the pressure. That's the magic of what the blockchain does. Otherwise we're always tied to the markets in flux, wondering whether we might get wiped out tomorrow, or whether Bitcoin or Ethereum will survive. With a stablecoin you drop it in, and go back to work.
Ashton: Facebook and governments are looking at creating their own stablecoins. Will people adopt them?▶ 12:26
John: I promise you every government crypto dollar, crypto yen, crypto pound and euro is already coming. They are the blockchain concept of cryptocurrency weaponized into a powerful microscope that will see and record, and even begin to anticipate, every penny you make or spend. That is where this is headed. They will ban privacy coins just before, or maybe just after, releasing their own crypto dollar. That's civil disobedience: you don't have to use it, unless somebody comes by with a gun.
With privacy coins there is nothing to smell, nothing to see.
This interview has been edited for length and clarity. Recorded December 2019.

