Skip to content

The CCS Interview

Hoskinson says Clarity Act would label new crypto projects securities by default

Charles Hoskinson, co-founder of Ethereum and founder and CEO of Input Output Global, spoke to CCS in April 2026 about the Midnight privacy network, AI agents and the stalled Clarity Act in the US. At the time, he argued the bill would hurt new crypto projects and set out how he thought US crypto legislation should be built instead.

Interview by Ashton Addison Recorded April 2026 9 min read

Key takeaways

  • Privacy and identity infrastructure are structural requirements for blockchain adoption, not optional features, as transparency enables future de-platforming and economic censorship.
  • The Clarity Act requires fundamental rebuilding rather than refinement to properly address institutional adoption concerns around sensitive data on-chain.
  • Fourth-generation blockchain technology must enable selective disclosure—proving attributes like location or ethnicity while preserving privacy—to support regulated business use cases.
  • Cross-chain interoperability standards and multi-chain infrastructure are essential for consumer adoption, requiring users to remain unaware they are using cryptocurrency.
  • Midnight is designed as ecosystem-agnostic privacy infrastructure for Bitcoin, Ethereum, Cardano, and Solana rather than a single-chain solution.

The unfinished job

Ashton Addison: Whatever the price of Bitcoin or Ethereum, you keep building. Why?▶ 00:47

Charles Hoskinson: It can't be about the money. I've made enough over the years, and if you were around when Bitcoin was a dollar and you're still here, you're either the world's worst businessman or you're here for philosophy. I'm here for philosophy, and the job isn't done. Satoshi's vision had clear action items. One is a decentralized world financial operating system. We've made enormous progress in 15 years with real-world assets and stablecoins, but we haven't achieved it. Two, it has to be resilient and decentralized, and if anything, systems are re-centralizing for efficiency, which is a problem for us as an industry. Three, we're missing what's needed to make this safe for everybody. We don't have privacy, so everything you do is recorded and can be used against you whenever it's politically convenient. Nor do we have identity, which you need to sort regulated from unregulated business and permissioned from permissionless. So we started from first principles and asked what the missing pieces are. Midnight is built for everyone, not just Cardano: Bitcoin, Ethereum, Solana and the off-chain world too. It's the last major thing I'll work on before I retire. Cardano took me 10 years, so I might be here for quite some time.

Ashton: Midnight isn't just for Cardano. What does it offer beyond moving assets between chains?▶ 06:43

Charles: If they have to know how crypto works or what chain they're on, you've done it wrong. The consumer shouldn't even know they're using crypto. Take Tinder. Your only basis is a picture and a chat log, but how do you know it's real, or that it's not a bot? You want selective disclosure, plus verification of that disclosure. The same technology works at a conference like Token2049. An investor who only wants to meet DEXes on Solana, and DEXes that only want to meet real VCs, can each verify the other before meeting. It could also power a lawful marketplace where you prove you have a zero-day exploit and sell it back to the company, instead of accepting a $500 bug bounty. Those are three very different use cases, and none of them should be chain-specific. So you step away from the chain and the cryptography, and put a good UX on top, which we call the Midnight Passport. There's also a bigger shift. By 2035, the overwhelming majority of internet searches and commerce will be agents working on behalf of humans. Agents can't read a smile or a frown, so their language is proofs. Blockchains are a trust engine, so this is the agents' commercial layer, and the missing piece is a proof layer. And the more you share with an agent without rules, the more whoever runs that agent knows about you. You need controls and guardrails, and those come from blockchain technology.

If they have to know how crypto works or what chain they're on, you've done it wrong.

Stablecoins and the Clarity Act

Ashton: AI agents may end up making more payments than people, probably in stablecoins. How much does stablecoin legislation matter for Midnight?▶ 14:08

Charles: We have the GENIUS Act, which created rules of the road. MiCA has rules of the road, and so does the rest of the world. Stablecoins are here to stay and they're fully regulated now, so that's not a problem anymore. The bigger challenge is the broader ecosystem of cryptocurrencies and DeFi, because stablecoins are seldom used as a stablecoin. They're a mechanism for commerce, always in reference to some other digital asset. It's like the Fun Factory arcade in Maui when I was a kid. You put a dollar in, you get tokens, and you put them in the machines. Stablecoins are the tokens, but without the arcade games there's no real point in having them. Unfortunately, that's where the Clarity Act comes in, and we haven't been able to get there as an ecosystem.

Ashton: What does good crypto legislation need, and how do you balance privacy with compliance?▶ 21:07

Charles: First, you can't do big legislative packages in a world without bipartisanship. There's also a perception that once something passes, it can't be changed. The 1933 securities law is 93 years old, and we still can't change the definition of a security. So start by updating that definition to add a category for blockchain-based or digital securities. Then the blockchain becomes a disclosure mechanism, and a hook for rulemaking that can allow ZK disclosure and other things. You shouldn't prescribe technology by statute. The European Union prescribed USB 2, and then USB 3 came out. Rulemaking, in consultation with industry through a self-regulatory model, is how you handle technology. Disclosure today assumes a company that speaks for the security, because that's how it worked in a paper economy in 1933. In 2026 a security can be decentralized. Any entity could disclose, and an exchange could do it on behalf of a decentralized application, as MiCA does. Right now, being labeled a security means you can't comply and have no liquidity. There's no path to decentralization either, because you have to stick around to keep disclosing. A decentralized digital security category would resolve about 70 to 80% of the issues we're having with DeFi. It would also solve Brian Armstrong's issue with his yield-bearing stablecoin. He could create a regular stablecoin under the GENIUS Act and a secondary token that's a security and pays yield. Without that category, the Clarity Act has to treat a yield-bearing stablecoin as a commodity, and the CFTC has to build a miniature SEC with no funding or mandate.

Ashton: Isn't passing the Clarity Act better than nothing, given that Democrats could take control and delay legislation for years?▶ 43:50

Charles: If it does happen, it will kill the American cryptocurrency industry in its current form. The idea that it's better than nothing is being propagated especially by the XRP side, and it's materially wrong. Under the old ambiguous laws, we were winning court cases. XRP won its case. Under this law, if Ripple were founded today, XRP would be a security. So would Ethereum and ADA, and a Gensler-esque SEC would have the law on its side. Under the mature blockchain test in the current version, there'd be no way to grow into a mature blockchain, because you wouldn't get the community growth or the liquidity. The first test of any legislation is whether the winners would still be winners. If the answer is no, you have to double-check. And if you pass this, you won't be able to change it, and Democrats will at some point be able to weaponize it. I'd much rather fight a court case with ambiguity than fight a court case where the law is not on my side. If that means waiting until 2029, we can wait.

A better way to write the rules

Ashton: The US wants to be the crypto capital of the world, but crypto is global. How should it have approached regulation?▶ 33:34

Charles: It would have been easy. Invite regulators from other countries to a workshop in Washington for a few days to talk about normalizing regulation. It's a great honor for a mid-level bureaucrat in a small country to be invited to the White House or Treasury, so they'd say yes. You ask them all the same questions. What worked? What didn't? Where are you getting tax compliance, and where are criminals using it? Then you hold an interagency show and tell with FinCEN, the DOJ, the SEC, the CFTC and others, and extract basic principles of interoperability. You also ask what statutory flexibility each country has. We saw this with Sarbanes-Oxley, passed in 2003 after Enron. The next day, Australia and other countries passed the same law, because they wanted to be interoperable with the US standard. In parallel, you send the major companies a questionnaire of a few hundred questions and give them 90 days. The most active participants join an industry steering committee, and those become the founding members of a self-regulatory organization. Then you sit down with leaders in Congress and the Senate and ask what's on the table and how to make it bipartisan. I worked on the Financial Innovation Act in 2022, which we wrote to be modular. Each part could be passed individually, section by section, over about five or six bills across two years.

Ashton: You've had to become an advocate and lobbyist as well as a builder. Why take such a public stand on Clarity?▶ 46:43

Charles: You always have to be an advocate for your industry and your ideas. If you're creating a new industry, you have an obligation to set the rules up for it. What I mind is when nepotism and corruption leak in, and when people know better. Let me be clear: Clarity in its current form is good for me. If it passes, what I've built isn't a security and my competitors will be. But I want people to build on Cardano and Midnight and issue their own tokens, and I can't allow them to face that scrutiny. Cardano, Bitcoin, Ethereum and XRP got where they are because ambiguity gave us the freedom to grow and build a large base of holders. If we take that away, we've said we were allowed to succeed and then pulled the ladder up behind us. That's what the banks and Wall Street do. I'm happy to be the guy who says the quiet part out loud, and to fight for the industry as a whole.

I'd much rather fight a court case with ambiguity than fight a court case where the law is not on my side.

Self-custody and Midnight's rollout

Ashton: Beyond contacting their representatives, what can people do to make this vision happen?▶ 55:15

Charles: Embrace decentralization. The more people and money in truly decentralized protocols, whether Ethereum, Cardano, Midnight or Bitcoin, the better. They're not special because a law or a politician made them special. They're special because of what they do. Understand self-custody and self-sovereign identity, own your keys and your wallet, and move your assets there. If more people do, the political cost of shutting it down gets too high. If crypto were at 2013 levels today, it would be illegal, but there's too much money in it now. So they're trying to control it by convincing you to hand it to a bank or buy an ETF. They can't control it if every American holds crypto in their own wallet, and they can't ban non-custodial wallets then. It's not about voting for politician A or B. Vote with your feet. Move from the US dollar and the legacy financial system into crypto, hold your own keys, and embrace protocols that are truly decentralized.

Ashton: Midnight has just launched. When can viewers start using the wallet and digital identity you described?▶ 1:12:09

Charles: You build in stages. First come demos and getting people aligned. Then there are several dimensions to wire up: how this works with chain abstraction across multiple chains, how it connects to the DApp layer, and how it connects to the actual devices. We have a dedicated trusted execution group working on access to iPhone and Android. Expect demos throughout the spring and summer, and then it starts rolling out. Nobody creates a Midnight Passport just because. You bundle it with an experience. We built Midnight City, an agentic civilization at midnight.city where you can buy agents and embed them in the city. We'll connect the passport to that, and the key is to get five or ten experiences in different verticals linked to the passport back end. After that it's one click for everything else. Regulated flows are a good example. We've asked exchange partners whether someone who has already done KYC could create an account in one click. We just announced the Monument Bank deal, which tokenizes deposits on the Midnight blockchain, and that's instructive for banks with one foot in crypto. Recovery matters too. After 15 years, the number one thing every user tells me is that they're afraid of messing up and losing all their money. So when you create a wallet, you create a recovery schema at the same time. Our hope is that the easiest way to use any cryptocurrency is with a Midnight Passport.

This interview has been edited for length and clarity. Recorded April 2026.

Charles Hoskinson
Charles HoskinsonCharles Hoskinson is an American entrepreneur and the CEO and founder of Input Output (IOG, formerly IOHK), the research and engineering company behind the Cardano blockchain and the Midnight privacy network. Born in Hawaii in 1987, he studied mathematics at Metropolitan State University of Denver… Full profile →
Share this interviewXLinkedIn
▶ Watching the interview