Skip to content

The CCS Interview

Panther's Anish Mohammed: zero knowledge lets privacy and compliance coexist

Anish Mohammed is co-founder, CTO and chief scientist of Panther Protocol. In this conversation, recorded in May 2022, he explains how Panther offers private DeFi strategies with optional KYC and selective disclosure. He also argues that zero knowledge proofs can reconcile privacy with regulation, and says what he expected for zero knowledge layer 2s at the time.

Interview by Ashton Addison Recorded May 2022 4 min read

Key takeaways

  • Panther Protocol enables private DeFi strategies through zero knowledge proofs while maintaining optional KYC and selective transaction disclosure to regulators.
  • Privacy mechanisms in Panther provide resistance to MEV attacks like front-running and sandwiching by obscuring transaction origins and user identity.
  • Z-assets function similarly to wrapped assets but incorporate game theoretic privacy mining where multiple users in a pool provide plausible deniability about transaction sources.
  • Panther facilitates cross-chain strategy deployment with privacy, allowing users to move assets between chains and access different yield opportunities without revealing their activities.
  • Zero knowledge proofs represent a paradigm shift enabling the coexistence of privacy and compliance in DeFi through cryptographic proof mechanisms.

A private strategy layer for DeFi

Ashton Addison: What is Panther Protocol, and what problem does it solve?▶ 00:22

Anish Mohammed: It depends on who I'm talking to. If you come from traditional finance, I say it's an economic dark pool on demand: a way to deploy a strategy and still keep it private. If you come from DeFi, I say it's a private DeFi strategy with the ability to do KYC and selective disclosure. Right now nobody can run a private strategy on DeFi that is shielded from everybody else. That is what Panther does. There is also the extra possibility of doing KYC, so that if you want, you can reveal a subset or all of your transactions to a tax authority such as the IRS, or HMRC in the UK.

Ashton: Transactions on Ethereum DEXs and Bitcoin are public and traceable. How does Panther add privacy?▶ 01:53

Anish: Providing privacy for transactions gives you a free benefit: resistance to MEV attacks, such as front-running and sandwiching. Imagine a glass house. You walk in and turn yourself into multiple copies, and each copy can transact. Only you know how many copies exist and which one did what. When you walk in you can be checked through KYC if you choose, so later you can prove which copy did what. We then use zero knowledge proof mechanisms plus some game-theoretic mechanisms, so your transactions look to the outside world as if they came from Panther Protocol, not from you. Say you hold XRP, which has no native DeFi yield. You bring it into Panther as a zAsset, cross to Ethereum and deploy a strategy privately, earning a yield you can't get on the layer one. Outsiders may see a strategy being run, but they won't know it's you. At the end you go back to your native chain and asset. You pay a small charge of 30 to 100 basis points, with the higher end for multi-leg strategies.

Zero knowledge lets you prove a claim without revealing it, so privacy and authenticity can coexist.

zAssets and the anonymity set

Ashton: Is a zAsset like wrapped Bitcoin, but with a zero knowledge proof?▶ 06:56

Anish: Yes, that's a really good way of describing it. But if there were only wrapping, and the only assets were the ones you put in, you'd have a problem. That is why there is a game-theoretic aspect too. Imagine a room with 100,000 people in it. Someone gets out and you have to guess who it was. That is the zAsset construct. Through privacy mining, people are compensated for staying in the room, which is the equivalent of putting assets into the pool. So it's not just your one asset in there. Other people have already put in assets too, which makes it pretty hard to guess that it's you.

Privacy versus compliance

Ashton: Regulators are looking harder at DeFi. Are privacy and compliance mutually exclusive?▶ 08:49

Anish: Zero knowledge proof systems are a real paradigm change. The big shift came with the non-interactive approach. Zero knowledge lets you prove a claim without revealing it, so privacy and authenticity can coexist. Regulators can have proof of the things they need, while ordinary citizens keep their privacy. Right now, on a blockchain, every transaction is publicly visible for eternity. Imagine you do something silly at 15 or 16, and 30 or 40 years later you run for US president. Somebody will dig everything up and build a story around it. Compare that with cash. A bank does your KYC, but when you pull money out of an ATM, nobody asks what you will do with it. You have privacy. A world where everything you do is transparent and everybody is tracking you, not just the bank, is a scary one. We need a nice balance. Zero knowledge proofs are one very interesting tool for that, along with secure multi-party computation and some game theory, which is what we use at Panther.

I don't have a crystal ball, and everybody in blockchain makes strong predictions that turn out to be way off.

Timelines and getting involved

Ashton: Many zero knowledge solutions are arriving, yet most people still just use Ethereum. When do you see them becoming the default?▶ 17:39

Anish: I don't have a crystal ball, and everybody in blockchain makes strong predictions that turn out to be way off. I have been in technology a long while, through cloud, big data, open source hardware, drones and now crypto. In February 2007 I met Andrew Jassy in a pub in London. If you had asked me then whether he would be CEO of Amazon and AWS would be a great business, I would have said very unlikely. What I can say is that significant money is going in. In the last six months Polygon bought one project for $250 million and another for $400 million. More than a billion dollars has been put into this ecosystem, and where significant money and people are working on it, there is a higher chance it succeeds. Over roughly the last five or six years the technology has improved a lot. Will zero knowledge solve the layer 2 problem in the next 12 to 18 months? I'm not 100 percent certain, but I would put it at 50 to 60 percent. Rollups increase throughput and reduce the fees you pay to the network, which is a strong incentive.

Ashton: How can viewers follow Panther's progress and get involved with the community?▶ 24:19

Anish: Start with our website. There is a series of blogs, and we've become far more consistent about publishing. We also have a larger research team now, about half a dozen people working with me, including cryptographers and a game theorist. Announcements appear on the blog, and we have a Discord and a Telegram. If you have time and patience, the blogs and our updated white paper will give you a good idea of what Panther is trying to do, what we've achieved and what we intend to do. We haven't explained everything to the degree that you could go and build it yourself, but we do explain it.

This interview has been edited for length and clarity. Recorded May 2022.

Anish Mohammed
Anish MohammedAnish Mohammed is Co-Founder, CTO and Chief Scientist of Panther Protocol, a zero-knowledge privacy and compliance protocol for decentralized finance. He has more than 20 years of experience in security and cryptography, and trained first as a medical doctor before moving into information security. He… Full profile →
Share this interviewXLinkedIn
▶ Watching the interview