Skip to content

The CCS Interview

Collective Intelligence Labs CEO: Multi-chain Web3 needs no central token

Alex Shkor is CEO and co-founder of Collective Intelligence Labs, which is designing a layered architecture meant to let one deployment run across many blockchains. In this conversation, recorded in February 2023, he explains how the design works, why he says it needs no central token, and what the team planned for 2023. Everything below reflects what was said at the time.

Interview by Ashton Addison Recorded February 2023 5 min read

Key takeaways

  • Collective Intelligence Labs proposes a five-layer web3 architecture enabling simultaneous deployment of applications and assets across multiple blockchains without manual redeployment.
  • The platform eliminates the need for a central governance token while requiring standardized protocols established through a decentralized council of industry participants.
  • An aggregation layer with decentralized routers optimizes transaction execution by selecting the most cost-effective blockchain and managing necessary cross-chain data communication.
  • The first prototype focuses on minting NFTs across multiple networks simultaneously, with users unaware of which blockchain executes their transaction.
  • Current bridge technologies represent temporary solutions rather than complete interoperability, as assets remain isolated to individual chains despite transfer mechanisms.

One deployment, many chains

Ashton Addison: What is Collective Intelligence Labs building, and how does it relate to a multi-chain future?▶ 00:49

Alex Shkor: Multi-chain is the future. We all want our apps deployed on multiple chains rather than existing in one ecosystem. Right now you have to deploy in several ecosystems and interconnect them, and that interconnectivity is quite limited. We came up with what we call a complete industry architecture that unites all the players. You deploy your dApp just once, on the whole Web3, and the underlying logic can redeploy it into different blockchains. As a developer or user, you mint your NFT or create your DAO in Web3 and you don't even know where it's executed. That's the ultimate user experience we want for Web3.

Ashton: DeFi has been growing since 2020, yet the ecosystem is still fragmented and bridges keep getting exploited. Why hasn't this been solved?▶ 02:00

Alex: All the bridges and current technologies are still hot fixes. It's not complete multi-chain or complete interconnectivity, because we still have to move assets from one chain to another. What we want is for your asset to exist on blockchains simultaneously. Data consistency is resolved through two layers, the relay layer and the core layer. The complete Web3 architecture has five layers: application, aggregation, execution, relay and core. It's the holistic infrastructure you need to deploy any smart contract on all blockchains simultaneously.

You deploy your dApp just once, on the whole Web3, and the underlying logic can redeploy it into different blockchains.

No central token, shared standards

Ashton: How long has the team been working on this, and what was the breakthrough?▶ 04:10

Alex: We've been working on this for a couple of years. We first came up with a multi-relay architecture, where one blockchain can be connected to multiple relays, for example Polkadot and Kusama simultaneously. That's still not the case even now, and it was quite a breakthrough for us about two years ago. But even if you connect multiple blockchains to one relay, there's still an incentive to create different, segregated ecosystems. The aha moment came when we questioned whether the architecture needs a central token at all. I concluded that there is a need for an institution to govern the infrastructure, but there's no need for a central token. That insight is what allows us to unite all the players and ecosystems in a single network.

Ashton: Do you need layer 1 protocols to implement something for compatibility, or can you do it permissionlessly?▶ 05:56

Alex: We'll be able to deploy our primitives to Ethereum, and it will become compatible with the architecture. But deciding what the primitive is, the standard for the whole Web3 stack, is a separate matter. That's why we're also creating a DAO, a council made up of players from different industry participants, influencers and technologies. They will decide the standard for data format, for NFTs and so on. It's a necessary step, because we can only unite the networks when we have a standardized pipeline of technologies.

Ashton: Are you starting with dApps, digital assets or NFTs, and what is the priority?▶ 07:09

Alex: Right now we're focused on building the first infrastructure prototype, which will let you mint NFTs on multiple networks simultaneously. You mint the NFT and you don't even know where it's minted, because you don't care. It's minted wherever the buyer is buying. Then we'll integrate more capabilities, allowing you to create DAOs, and eventually any kind of application on top of this multi-chain Web3 metaprotocol.

Routing, cost and security

Ashton: If you mint across multiple blockchains, what underlying security governs that process?▶ 08:31

Alex: In this architecture, users don't interact directly with blockchains. They always go through the aggregation layer. When you send a transaction to mint an NFT, it lands in the aggregation layer, which is connected to multiple blockchains. A decentralized router knows which blockchain is most optimal for your operation, since some operations are cheaper on one chain than another. It also knows which blockchain has the data needed for execution. If a chain doesn't have all the data, it triggers interchain communication, which is more expensive. The router operator makes money on the difference between the estimated and actual execution costs.

Ashton: So minting through Polkadot, say, would cost the same as going there directly?▶ 10:07

Alex: At first, yes. But once this protocol is launched and implemented, the cost of operating on Web3 will drop dramatically, because it creates competition between all the blockchains for cost-effective execution. That's not the case now. When you're locked into an ecosystem like Ethereum, you stay locked in even if prices are high. With millions of transactions going through a decentralized router that finds the optimal path, every blockchain is incentivized to offer fast, efficient and cheap execution. On security, you actually get the combined security of all these networks. Even if Ethereum fully disappeared, I think the system would keep operating, because the data also lives on other blockchains, including ones that haven't been created yet.

There is a need for an institution to govern the infrastructure, but there's no need for a central token.

Too many layer ones, and the 2023 roadmap

Ashton: There are more and more layer 1 networks. Which ones do you start with?▶ 12:29

Alex: We can implement these primitives on different blockchains, and that makes them compatible with the architecture. It makes sense to focus first on an EVM implementation, because we can do it once and deploy to multiple chains. A Cosmos- or Substrate-based implementation is probably the second priority, and we're still deciding. Once the protocol is implemented and becomes a standard, all blockchains will be incentivized to implement it themselves. I don't worry about having a thousand layer ones. We call them execution layer chains, which is a more correct name, because L1 doesn't tell you what it actually does in the system. If you're not exposed to them, you don't care how many there are. Now you have to handle interoperability, transfers and wallets, and it gets crazy. It's like this conversation: we don't know whether our data is processed by a server in the Netherlands or somewhere else, and there's no reason we should.

Ashton: What are the major initiatives on the roadmap for 2023?▶ 15:16

Alex: One is launching architecture design sessions. This Web3 metaprotocol is so big, with so many participants, that designing it should be a collective effort, so we're inviting top experts to help detail it. We have the higher-level architecture. Now we need a specification for every layer, every node and every layer cluster. Once we have that, it will lead to implementations in different verticals and the creation of new businesses. The sessions will be held every month. We'll also build our own businesses on the execution, aggregation and application layers. The DAO has already launched and now has 19 members, and we'll keep onboarding more because we want to be more inclusive.

This interview has been edited for length and clarity. Recorded February 2023.

Alex Shkor
Alex ShkorAlex Shkor is a software architect and entrepreneur who is CEO and co-founder of Collective Intelligence Labs, a Web3 infrastructure developer. He studied computer science at the Belarusian State University of Informatics and Radioelectronics and began his career as a senior software engineer at Itransition… Full profile →
Share this interviewXLinkedIn
▶ Watching the interview