Alejo Pinto / Pontem

Move Virtual Machine brings blockchain to mainstream adoption

InterviewFebruary 15, 202430:26

In this episode

Ashton Addison speaks with Alejo Pinto, Chief Growth Officer of Pontem, on their recent $6M raise for Lumio Layer 2 blockchain, the power and advantages of Move VM as a programming language, How AI will reshape DAO’s and humanity overall, and the lead up to the next stages of Lumio’s protocol.

Key takeaways
  • Pontem operates as a product studio with live products including Pontem Wallet and Liquid Swap AMM on Aptos, now developing Lumio Layer 2 for Ethereum.
  • Move VM is a Rust-based programming language created by Meta in 2019 that offers better security features than Solidity, including native formal verification and parallel transaction execution.
  • Lumio aims to provide a vendor-neutral way for traditional finance companies to deploy applications on Ethereum using Move or alternative VMs instead of being locked into the EVM.
  • Solidity was designed as a proof-of-concept in 2014 and has structural vulnerabilities like reentrancy errors that caused the DAO hack, whereas Move was purpose-built for blockchain applications.
  • Pontem plans to port its existing wallet, AMM, and lending protocols built on Move to Ethereum through Lumio while maintaining composability across different blockchain environments.

Chapters

Read the interview

Pontem's Alejo Pinto: Move VM can upgrade Ethereum's 'public cloud'

Alejo Pinto, co-founder and chief growth officer of Pontem Network, explains why the team wants to bring the Move language to Ethereum through its Lumio layer 2. He also covers DeFi security, the role of AI and what Pontem planned for 2024. The conversation was recorded in February 2024, when Lumio was still on testnet.

A product studio heading to Ethereum

Ashton: What is Pontem, and what are you building? 00:22

Alejo Pinto: The best way to think about Pontem is as a product studio, like a game studio with several individual products underneath. Two are live: Pontem Wallet and the Liquid Swap AMM, both category leaders on Aptos. Now that we have those two beachheads, we're filling out the vertical integration of our product stack, down to the execution layer. That's Lumio, which is on testnet. It will let us launch the Move VM, and in future other alternative VMs, in a credibly neutral way on Ethereum. As traditional finance companies like Fidelity and BlackRock come to Ethereum, they can choose how to deploy their applications, rather than being locked into the EVM. Solidity is a bit like JavaScript, and you wouldn't build mission-critical banking infrastructure on JavaScript.

Ashton: Is the virtual machine a protocol that connects different blockchains? 03:07

Alejo Pinto: Think of it as a credibly neutral way to deploy applications: the AMM, the wallet, and also lending protocols built with Move. Think of public blockchains as public clouds. If you were vendor-locked into building your backend only with JavaScript, that would be a really bad experience. We're essentially upgrading Ethereum, the public cloud infrastructure, so that we can deploy applications built with a better virtual machine and a better language, and be competitive there. This can be applied to other blockchains too. Initially these environments will be isolated, but we're also researching ways to connect them.

Read the full interview →

Transcript

Read the full transcript 5,757 words, auto-generated and lightly edited

I'm ashon Addison from the Crypto Coin Show and today on blockchain interviews we have allejo Pinto the chief growth officer from pontum Leo welcome to the show and thanks for taking the time thank you for having me here excited to dive into it definitely a lot to talk about I know pontum is working on quite a few different things I would love for you if you could explain to

start off on sort of what is pontum what are you guys building what's the mission and the vision of the protocol and then we can dive into all the details yeah so the best way to think about pontum is as a product Studio or as an analog a game studio with several individual products underneath so the two products that are live now are pontum wallet and the liquid swap amm

those are category leaders on Aptos we have over 40 50% market share and trading volume for the amm the wallet is hard to gauge specific numbers that are on chain but you know we're pretty confident we're we're up there in the number one our number two spot and now that we have these two Beach heads we're filling out the entire vertical integration for our

product stack and going down to the execution layer and with that we have lumio which is now on testnet and that's going to allow us to launch the M VM and in the future other alternative VMS in incredibly neutral way on ethereum so that as traditional Tech traditional finance companies let's say Fidelity black come to ethereum to deploy their applications they have the choice of

deploying with move Solano BM cosm wum see you know whatever whatever you want to deploy with right now it's possible with move and then not be vendor locked into the evm which carries a lot of user let's say like user error in a way like there's a lot of ways you can shoot yourself in the foot and the way that the code is then structured is like

very janky and patchy and I can go into details of this but the just on paper objectively move and rust are you know better structured languages and when you're building Mission critical applications which is going to be our financial infrastructure you know if we really do want to trust us treasuries you know us cash you know the stock market on the blockchain we need you

know a foundation that is better than JavaScript think of ebm this compare various times right evm is kind of like the or solidity is kind of like JavaScript and you know you wouldn't build your banking banking Mission critical infrastructure on JavaScript so we're we're trying to enable in incredibly neutral way these alternative BMS across different blockchains because

people right now are B their locked into these languages and these virtual machines so that's the vision with lumio and that enables us to entirely essentially lift and shift our Tech stock so the amm the wallet connected composable protocols and then Deploy on ethereum and you know in the future other chains where we can support move and in other alternative EMS MH wow

incredible that is quite a bit and now so there's a wallet there's an amm which is the same as a decks for the most part there may be differences you can explain and then the whole virtual machine is like a protocol that allows you to connect different blockchains all together as well is that correct so think of the virtual machine as a decentralized ibly neutral way to deploy

these applications the amm Dex the wallet but then also horizontally lending protocols that are built with move so imagine imagine if think of think of public clouds public blockchains as public clouds and imagine if you're vendor locked in to only build with JavaScript you can only build literally your backend infrastructure with JavaScript that's a really bad user

experience so what we're trying to do is up upgrade the public Cloud the ethereum public Cloud so that you can also deploy with this new language move which is rust based and it's just a lot better and I can go into some of the details of Why move is better than than solidity but yeah I mean it's it's like we're upgrading we're essentially upgrading

ethereum the public Cloud infrastructure so that we can take our applications which are fundamentally better because they're built with a better virtual machine with a better language and then be competitive on ethereum and you know this can be applied to other blockchains initially it'll be isolated like these environments are going to be isolated but we're also

researching ways to connect them MH very interesting aljo and with that move language I'm I'm personally have not heard of it before I know rust salana based on Rust language and most people know that solidity in the ethereum ecosystem is has been around the longest in the blockchain world but I have not heard of move is it just that it's brand new or is there a reason

that other blockchains have not chosen this language yet yeah so move has actually been around since 2019 it was first Inception at meta or Facebook this was buil purpose build for the Libra project move Sam blacksher he was at sui was one of the inventors of move he has like a PhD in computer Linguistics or computer languages and

you can think of move as the best of solidity and the best of rust so it's design after rust so you have resource model it's a static type language you can it supports concurrency natively so you can do paralyzed transaction execution so parallel you know parallel VMS has been like a trending topic so this you're able to do this natively with move you also have

Feature safety features built in natively like you can do formal verification to make sure that so for example the kyber swap hack was a overflow error so that could be built into so they could you know you could have like a third party library on ethereum which you need to trust to do the formal verification or that could be built into the VM natively which it

is in move so move is essentially you know the attempt that taking the best of what exists which is rust and then what's cool about solidity again I no dig on solidity but it's kind of like a proof of concept like think think about it from the people that built the evm and solidity like it was 2014 vitalic nobody had even vitalic himself didn't

think his idea had any legs you know he tried to do something Orin to colored coins on bitcoin and he was like guys what if we just do this separately you know it can have proof of proof of work maybe transition proof of stake eventually and we need a virtual machine so we have essentially programmability these turn complete software that can then be deployed

and create these decentralized applications and that had never been done before right and they literally had to come up with a virtual machine the virtual machine is very simple you have these operation codes that are like you know math essentially like you know add this subtract this divide and then you need an abstract language to create the business logic to say you know you

know operate operate these op codes to do what this abstract you know business logic is saying and when they did that they had to come up with entirely new language I believe at the time Gavin Woods who's like at polka dot now was the CTO and you know this is like having to put together an entire language so you can launch this thing and so far it worked you know it's worked pretty

well but there's also a lot of like the biggest issue which I don't know if they took into account was Dynamic dispatch so this led to re-entrance erors and the infamous Dow hack where like literally ethereum split into into ethereum classic because there was a smart contract hack and they literally Fork the chain whether you believe in the principles of immutability or not is

up to you but you know they literally forked the chain to give the money back to people and that was ethereum right and that was due to a Smart contract error which if they had if they had used move from the beginning re-entrancy errors wouldn't have been an issue the Dow hack would have never happened right so yeah that's all to say that ethereum you know gave it a first try

with the evm but we don't have to be stuck to this like proof of concept language that was that was shipped and you know future iterations for future blockchain so DM now apto sui right they chose move because that's what they incubated when they were at meta and it is purpose buil for blockchains therefore there's no reason why you wouldn't be able to Port it over

back to ethereum and say look you know we don't have to be stuck with this proof of concept that was kind of like rushed into Market it does work but it was It was kind of rushed and there's a ton of you know improvements that could be done and that's where something like move comes into play and the fact that no one has done it's like a big

Market opportunity to go and do it I appreciate that backstory allejo and I was around during the Dow days but it's interesting to hear it from sort of the programming language perspective and the specific issues with solidity and why we're now moving to version two of programmability and version three with these new programming languages that are

better but with defi specifically and decentralized finance applications it seems that right now because probably part in part because of the network effect a lot of the defi apps that were built in 2020 and when defi really started to explode we based on ethereum and there's a lot of total value locked in there still which will eventually probably move

onto these new move VM ecosystems whether it's through the help of quantum or through other mechanisms can you explain exactly how that would work in making the functionality and the security better for the current defi apps that are on ethereum through move and through pontum yeah so if you think of the upgrade path for these protocols there's two and people you know users out there

should be aware of these so when a protocol has upgradeability that means that there's people out there with multi with multi sigs that can upgrade the protocol now that is something people should be aware of because that same upgradeability can lead to vulnerabilities like the developers could turn malicious or those that multi could be hacked and then

potentially that protocol be upgraded to withdraw all the funds add a withdraw function all the funds in there are are withdrawn right look at serum this happened to serum everybody freaked out when FTX collapsed and no one knew who had the upgrade keys to serum right that you know go go check the docs of all your favorite D apps and make sure

that they're actually decentralized that there's no upgradeability paths and if there are then make sure that the multi sigs are you know secured by trusted people and keep in mind that at any point in time those trusted people could get hacked or could be malicious and then you know essentially you know take away the money that's in that D app

on ethereum so this is more so I would You' see this more on like the newer chains like salana and apos Etc where like the upgradeability they even built in upgradeability into the into the mov M so you can choose to deploy your contract with upgradeability that's how common this is but again it's like a design architecture from the developers to code in how decentralized they

want these applications to be so Unis swap is immutable so even if you held a gun to the head of the developers you know they couldn't take the money out of there right that's good but then that leads to these upgrade paths where you need to launch like V1 V2 V3 and then all the liquid needs to migrate from V1 to V2 because the upgrades are like

entirely new contracts MH so that's all to say in a long long about about way is that the next versions of these protocols there's no reason why they wouldn't be able to be launched and move and rust right if you have a credibly neutral way to deploy applications and move and you're seeing this with sushi who is now on Aptos or pancake swap who's now on apto these are

incumbents and evm that have now started to migrate and have versions on move and then as they launch future versions do they want to continue maintaining evm and move or if they have something better like move to continue maintaining future versions would they just translate to the better language and that's that's the bet we're making and you know I think I think it's

possible like just future versions will be in move you know older versions will will still be relatively you know people might still use them but you would expect most people to migrate to the newer versions and then if you have composability between evm and move which we have in the same environment on lumio but you could also have composability to

other EV evm chains like Bas and op mayet Etc all l2s that are evm based you can still do contract calls between let's say an A or a vrum on op mainnet that enables you to still have like API calls and to move contracts so we're building this in a way where you still maintain composability with evm so all the Legacy stuff that's been built can still work and then as you

develop new new contracts new versions of your products new Integrations you can still maintain those Legacy contracts and you know just like Bild with move into into the future yeah I mean we're just we're just trying to give people choice and with choice I think comes the ability to you know for this stuff to get more widely widely adopted definitely I appreciate that

explanation now I want to look at that Unis swap example that you gave as well they've gone from version one version two version three and they up upgraded the contracts and yeah it was like people had to merge the liquidity in to the new version now how much harder would it be for UNIS swap to say version 4 has now changed the programming language into move and what are the main

incentives or drivers that for the benefits of the users and the platform Itself by moving into the move VM for version 4 yeah so for an end user perspective it's somewhat margin improvements so for example move natively you can do paralyzed transaction execution so you could have two pools running in parallel so you could have WAP eth and usdc and WAP

Bitcoin and usdc operating at the same time right now the evm is sequential so you can't do that however there is coming so caveat there is coming paralyzed EVMS right so that's you know you could still do that with evm but move supports this natively arguably it'll have better performance also on cost so each transaction might cost you less gas so this is good for Bots that

are operating and you know need to manage their profits and gas so there's like these marginal improvements which is again comes from the backend infrastructure the contracts you know having a better base or better Foundation than evm and then you also gain things like the safety the safety feature so you don't have the re-entrancy errors that could happen

which is major hack that can happen you have the native prover built in so you can do formal verification to get all those benefits for the end user it should feel relatively the same you know you're you're performing the same actions but again it'll be probably like a little bit cheaper faster but the for the for the developers right that you know care about the stuff it's like

okay now we have a more solid app less likely to get hacked you know performing better and I think that has a network effect right if even like if a marginal improvements on performance and safety probably has a network effect because if you have a and b and they're both a commodity the one that has the marginal Improvement on performance and safety

is probably more likely to get ahead right so I would say those are the benefits the drawback is you know the Lindy effect of evm but over time if we have more applications built with move then you know that Lindy effect should should start to catch up with the evm okay good to know and I read recently that pontum had just raised 6 million for C financing for the L2 lumio

can can you talk a little bit more about lumio and with that raise closed what are sort of the next steps in growing out that part yeah so Lumia right now is a proof of concept on testnet and yeah we're we're able to scale the team and hire more people to take it onto Main net and yeah I mean essentially we need a lot of resources to do that mhm

awesome and does AI play a role in all of this now now that we're upgrading the programming languages making everything better I feel like AI made huge strides in 2023 and it's slowly creeping its way into making blockchain better as well is there an AI play with pontum yeah I mean AI at very different levels is interesting so right now we

have we actually have an AI product it's called pantum AI you can go on pontum doai and try it out it's an llm that we've embedded with crypto information so you can ask it things about apos things about ethereum we have unchain data on there that's very useful that's kind of like superficial level use of AI because you're still so AI fundamentally is a product around

Data and compute aggregation right so right now that's in Microsoft that's in Azor servers or you know maybe Facebook will have or apple will have their own servers and then they control all the data they control what gets published so like when you go on o on chbt and you're like you know I don't want to be just like you know show me some poop show me like an image

of poop and it's like oh that goes against our content policiy blah blah blah but it's like it's poop it's feces like whatever we see poop every day when you're picking up your dog's poop but now we're being we're literally being censored from looking at images of poop like that's kind of that's kind of scary so anyway I mean imagine if Google did that imagine if Google was

like sorry we can't show you images of poop because of our policy and like the only interface we had to search for stuff was this like centralized entity that now is literally thought controlling us so anyway how do you fix that you put you decentralize the AI you the data and compute aggregation can come on chain so you could put you know a lot of this data on

maybe like ipfs a lot of the like the gpus that are used for you know you could create networks of gpus that then provide compute for these LM models to be trained and operate so I think there's more interesting stuff coming for the interception of blockchain AI and it has to do with the decentralization of those data structures right so like I personally

wouldn't trust open AI with you know the stuff that I want to think about and you know asked the llm I might trust like my own machine so I might trust like you know a server in my house that I can like you know build an llm to answer questions and you maybe like replicate my own thoughts like maybe I feeded all my thoughts and it becomes like an llm of me but I wouldn't

trust that I wouldn't trust that to you know AWS oror or Microsoft right but then you might also but then your server inhouse is not going to be as powerful as like billions of dollars of infrastructure like literally huge server Farms that Microsoft can maintain this you know what assume to be like a sentian being right like the AGI is you know assumed to be a cian being so the

question is where do you want this cian being to be to be living how do how is it going to be controlled like just extrapolating a extrapolating AI 100 years you're going to have a cian being is that cian being going to be Microsoft or is that cian being going to be free and where if it's going to be free it probably has to live on the blockchain right that's like the only

machine that humans can't shut down like Bitcoin and ethereum they can't shut it down so yeah I mean I think I think as a as AI becomes more developed and that's just llms right you can think about these for machine learning algorithms for setting parameters on these these protocols right so a DA what's a DA what's a what's a what's

a corporation a corporation is a centralized autonomous organization right it's like Facebook it's centralized by Mark Mark has 50 or Elon a Tesla right centralized autonomous organization like Elon isn't doing everything there's a bunch of people doing stuff but he can say let's go A or B and then it moves that way a decentralized autonomous organization

you replace Mark you replace Tesla with these tokens that have literally onchain governance rights to update the parameters of the organization whether it's you know trading like a coinbase or you know L borrowing like a bank you know now the users the end users that have these tokens have the literally ability to vote on the parameter updates right and you know

these can be more complex like you could have end users upgrade you know have that's that's pretty dangerous but you could potentially have users upgrade the protocol to have new features right and then okay so that's a decentralized autonomous organization it's still people making decisions right and it's on the blockchain so it's programmable you don't need like to trust the a horse

and a telegram to like deliver the news and then someone to make the decision to put it in like if people if people vote on the blockchain to do it literally happens which is pretty powerful and also dangerous but now we're starting to migrate from centralized autonomous organizations to De centralized autonomous organizations and then the decentralized like the so

decentralized autonomous organizations I don't know what you would call this maybe like artificial artificially intelligent decentralized autonomous organizations imagine the inputs into the parameters no longer being humans now being like algorithms so the algorithm like so you could set the parameters for the lenb protocol LTV to be to be X or Y right that can be

like a human human main decision or it could be an AI That's learning that's like giving taking all these inputs from the market and then updating the parameters and then you remove humans from the equation you should probably still have humans kind of like check to make sure that doesn't go wrong but and like this like theoretically today you could do this you could have an

organization that's run by Ai and then it's literally and then imagine that AI again becomes cian and is able to make its own decisions so like okay they have an organization that's a dow and it's generating profits through like this protocol that's like trading and lending borrowing whatever now it has a treasury of a million dollars what if that AI is

like hey guys I want to invest in cars I think I think cars are the next thing you know we're going to have autonom just like we have autonomous trading we're going to have autonomous cars so then the AI says okay I'm going to put this billion dollars or million dollars or whatever and buy a bunch of Teslas and then that's going to feed our and like that could be done without

humans at all right like you could literally have these robots running organizations and I think I think unfortunately we're Beyond The Tipping Point of the AGI or like these autonomous robots just kind of like taking over the economy taking over you know everything that we do and you know it'll kind of be like planes right like right now you can think of Bitcoin as

like the you know the was it the right brothers or whoever like literally riding on a bicycle off a cliff and flying that was like Bitcoin and 100 years later you have you know Jets or you know that can break the speed of sound or it can you know get close to the speed of light maybe right maybe like drones that can and now similarly I think we're going to wake up

a 100 years and look in hind like damn like we let these robots start taking over the economy and like is that good or bad I mean if you have ownership and the robots potentially right but if you don't you might you might have just lost your job very interesting and I think you're completely right it's a great analogy about the right Brothers with

Bitcoin and with the introduction of AI it just grows exponentially faster every year you know it's it's been going for quite a long time but in the public eye the release of Chachi PT just one year ago and now the few versions later one year later are multitudes faster and that example about the AI Dows I definitely think that's coming I'm I'm

I'll be looking out for the AI Dow projects in the near future here so yeah it's it's it's a lot to follow because because of the exponential growth it's only going to continue to be more stuff and it's like how do you stay on top of it as a human to make sure that you don't lose your job or let you that you at least get a piece of the pie so that you can contribute and be

rewarded yeah I just hope that we create enough value with these robots and the people or whoever is in charge of Distributing the resources just make sure that everybody has enough food and shelter and water and we can all be happy you know I wouldn't mind if my food shelter and water is covered I wouldn't mind you know being like an artist or you know learning an

instrument but we need at least like food Water Shelter like basic needs Med and then I think people can be happy beyond that with that Financial but I don't know that sounds a little bit dystopian though well we will see and so I'm curious you know we don't have a lot of time left aljo but I'm curious on what your focus is in the near term here

with pontum and lumio see in the next six months or throughout 2024 what are you focused on in the project and what are sort of the next things that the public should expect to come out yeah really focusing on growing the current products that we have so amm and wallet and then by extension as we launch onto ethereum lumio adoption there so you know look to see more

Use cases for these don't want to reveal too much information on what we're planning with liquid swap but expect you know really low latency like high performance decks which I think hasn't really been done concertedly yet and making that essentially a norm or a standard for people to come use defi that's that's something that you know we're we're in

the works and I think within the next six months we'll be relaunch and excited to see come to life I think like just to give a little bit of alpha on Aptos and some of these you know next Generation blockchains you can start to match the performance of centralized exchanges so a big reason people use you know FTX or binance or whatever is because you know you don't have to you

don't have to wait three like an hour for your transaction to go through you don't have to pay like $4 do to do a basic trade but on apto salana sui you know these NextGen blockchains it starts to feel lot like a traditional web2 app and you know stuff like and like this is a simple one like why are people still using binance and okx when like FTX imploded like why are we still

using these centralized apps when we have Alternatives that are onchain you know you custody your own Keys I think the reason is that the infrastructure isn't there for it to feel like a like a web 2 app but that's you know that's coming oh I'm looking forward I guess yeah yeah it's it's been there's definitely just as I think what will happen in AI there'll be

an exponential growth where there'll be that aha moment whether it's aptose and move VM making a better user experience for dexus and then all of a sudden there'll be there'll be a pivot point where over 50% are using the decentralized in sort of more safe and secure way where they can they're trusting themselves rather than trusting whoever's at the back end of binance

to not have another FTX episode so I'm looking forward to that with the with the test net that's going on with lumio and just with the communities involved to follow along with the updates is it an incentivized test net or is there anything that people can do to test it out and contribute to lumio and pontum what can they do yeah we're rolling out the test and

and phases so we don't get dosed right now some Community ogs are able to use it so folks that have used the nfts or liquid swap on appos have been able to use it but we're opening up more in phases there's a weight list that people want to sign up and they can get notified as we open up more phases and more you know opportunities to get onto the

testet sounds great and I can leave the protocol links Social Links and weight list and everything in the show notes below as well I really do appreciate you coming in with all of this insight and there's just so much to learn especially with the amount of different blockchains VMS coming out new technology that's growing even faster and throw AI in the mix there

it's like it's hard to keep up so I do appreciate all your insights aljo and wishing you the best with pontum and lumio moving forward and let's definitely follow up in the near future sounds good yeah I'm happy to come on and talk about you know unrelated stuff to my project you know tangentially related so talk about other VMS talk about l2s in general talk about defi

even if it's not you know products that we're building I think Outlets like this are useful to get information out to people for them to be informed I think as people learn more you'll realize it looks a lot like should web too but just with some small caveats that are very important like the like custody your own keys don't just give them to

FTX yeah no definitely definitely a great Point same but different yeah same but different yeah amazing well thank you so much Alo I will talk to you very soon awesome Take Care thank you

More interviews

Browse all 1,089 interviews

Get new interviews firstCCS Insider, the free newsletter from Ashton Addison. Twice a week.